Key idea: P gives a positive iodoform test, so it is a methyl ketone. P is converted by MeMgBr, then acid and heat, into olefin Q. Ozonolysis of Q gives dicarbonyl R, and R undergoes intramolecular aldol to give S. Only one methyl ketone fits this whole sequence.
- Iodoform test: (C) is an ethyl ketone and (D) is a phenyl ketone, so both fail. Only (A) and (B), which contain −COCHX3, remain.
- Take (B), PhCH=C(CHX3)COCHX3. MeMgBr gives the tertiary allylic alcohol PhCH=C(CHX3)C(OH)(CHX3)X2.
- With HX2SOX4 and heat, the tertiary allylic cation attacks the benzene ring at the ortho position (intramolecular Friedel–Crafts). This gives Q, 1,1,2-trimethylindene.
- Ozonolysis of the C2=C3 bond of the indene gives the keto-aldehyde R, o-OHC−CX6HX4−C(CHX3)X2COCHX3.
- Base: the −COCHX3 group enolises and attacks the aryl CHO. This closes a six-membered ring, and dehydration gives S, a 1,1-dimethylnaphthalen-2(1H)-one.
- Check (A), PhCH=CHCOCHX3. The same steps give an R in which both carbonyls lack α-H (ArCHO and −C(CHX3)X2CHO). This R cannot undergo aldol condensation, so (A) fails.
Answer: (B)