RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 09 JAN S2+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Physics question — Errors in measurement and significant figures

For the four sets of three measured physical quantities as given below. Which of the following options is correct?
(i)(i) A1=24.36,B1=0.0724,C1=256.2A_1 = 24.36, B_1 = 0.0724, C_1 = 256.2
(ii)(ii) A2=24.44,B2=16.082,C2=240.2A_2 = 24.44, B_2 = 16.082, C_2 = 240.2
(iii)(iii) A3=25.2,B3=19.2812,C3=236.183A_3 = 25.2, B_3 = 19.2812, C_3 = 236.183
(iv)(iv) A4=25,B4=236.191,C4=19.5A_4 = 25, B_4 = 236.191, C_4 = 19.5

SOLUTION

The problem asks us to compare the algebraic sums Ai+Bi+CiA_i+B_i+C_i of four different data-sets and then decide which of the four statements given in the options describes their order correctly.

Whenever we add measured quantities we must obey the rule of significant figures meant for addition and subtraction.

Rule (state first): While adding or subtracting, the final result is written only up to that number of digits after the decimal point which is possessed by the addend having the least number of digits after the decimal point.

Now we evaluate every sum one by one, showing all arithmetic steps and then applying the above rule.

Set (i): A1=24.36,  B1=0.0724,  C1=256.2A_1=24.36,\;B_1=0.0724,\;C_1=256.2

Raw sum (ordinary addition, no rounding yet):

24.36+0.0724=24.432424.36 + 0.0724 = 24.4324

24.4324+256.2=280.632424.4324 + 256.2 = 280.6324

The three addends possess respectively 2, 4 and 1 decimal places; the least is 1. So we round the result to one place after the decimal:

280.6324⟶280.6280.6324 \longrightarrow 280.6

Set (ii): A2=24.44,  B2=16.082,  C2=240.2A_2=24.44,\;B_2=16.082,\;C_2=240.2

Raw sum:

24.44+16.082=40.52224.44 + 16.082 = 40.522

40.522+240.2=280.72240.522 + 240.2 = 280.722

Here the addends have 2, 3 and 1 decimal places; the least is again 1. So we round to one decimal place:

280.722⟶280.7280.722 \longrightarrow 280.7

Set (iii): A3=25.2,  B3=19.2812,  C3=236.183A_3=25.2,\;B_3=19.2812,\;C_3=236.183

Raw sum:

25.2+19.2812=44.481225.2 + 19.2812 = 44.4812

44.4812+236.183=280.664244.4812 + 236.183 = 280.6642

The numbers have 1, 4 and 3 decimal places; the least is 1. Rounding to one decimal place gives:

280.6642⟶280.7280.6642 \longrightarrow 280.7

Set (iv): A4=25,  B4=236.191,  C4=19.5A_4=25,\;B_4=236.191,\;C_4=19.5

Raw sum:

25+236.191=261.19125 + 236.191 = 261.191

261.191+19.5=280.691261.191 + 19.5 = 280.691

Now the addends have 0, 3 and 1 decimal places; the least is 0. Hence the answer must be rounded to no decimal places at all:

280.691⟶281280.691 \longrightarrow 281

We therefore have the four correctly rounded totals

A1+B1+C1=280.6,A2+B2+C2=280.7,A3+B3+C3=280.7,A4+B4+C4=281.\begin{aligned} A_1+B_1+C_1 &= 280.6,\\ A_2+B_2+C_2 &= 280.7,\\ A_3+B_3+C_3 &= 280.7,\\ A_4+B_4+C_4 &= 281. \end{aligned}

Arranging them in ascending order of magnitude gives

280.6  <  280.7=280.7  <  281,280.6 \; < \; 280.7 = 280.7 \; < \; 281,

or, written with the original symbols,

A1+B1+C1  <  A2+B2+C2  =  A3+B3+C3  <  A4+B4+C4.A_1+B_1+C_1 \; < \; A_2+B_2+C_2 \;=\; A_3+B_3+C_3 \; < \; A_4+B_4+C_4.

This statement is exactly what Option C expresses.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Errors in measurement and significant figures. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicErrors in measurement and significant figures
TypeMultiple choice