RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2013 · 09 APR ONLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2013 Physics question — Dimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations

From the following, the quantity (constructed from the basic constants of nature), that has the dimensions, as well as correct order of magnitude, vis-a-vis typical atomic size, is:

SOLUTION

To determine which quantity has the dimensions of length and the correct order of magnitude for a typical atomic size (approximately 10−1010^{-10} meters), we need to analyze each option by checking its dimensional formula. The basic constants involved are:

  • Electron charge ee with dimension [Q][Q] (charge).
  • Permittivity of free space ϵ0\epsilon_0 with dimension [M−1L−3T2Q2][M^{-1} L^{-3} T^{2} Q^{2}].
  • Electron mass mem_e with dimension [M][M] (mass).
  • Speed of light cc with dimension [LT−1][L T^{-1}].
  • Reduced Planck's constant ℏ\hbar with dimension [ML2T−1][M L^2 T^{-1}].

The dimension of length is [L][L]. We will evaluate each option step by step, ignoring dimensionless constants like 4π4\pi.

Option A: e24πϵ0mec2\frac{e^2}{4\pi\epsilon_0 m_e c^2}

Dimensions:
Numerator: [e2]=[Q2][e^2] = [Q^2].
Denominator: [ϵ0]=[M−1L−3T2Q2][\epsilon_0] = [M^{-1} L^{-3} T^{2} Q^{2}], [me]=[M][m_e] = [M], [c2]=[L2T−2][c^2] = [L^2 T^{-2}].
So, [ϵ0mec2]=[M−1L−3T2Q2]×[M]×[L2T−2]=[M0L−1T0Q2][\epsilon_0 m_e c^2] = [M^{-1} L^{-3} T^{2} Q^{2}] \times [M] \times [L^2 T^{-2}] = [M^{0} L^{-1} T^{0} Q^{2}].
Fraction: [Q2][L−1Q2]=[L]\frac{[Q^2]}{[L^{-1} Q^{2}]} = [L].

This has the dimension of length. The value is the classical electron radius, approximately 2.82×10−152.82 \times 10^{-15} meters, which is of the order of femtometers (typical nuclear size), not atomic size. However, it is the only option with the correct dimension.

Option B: 4πϵ0e2me2\frac{4\pi\epsilon_0 e^2}{m_e^2}

Dimensions:
Numerator: [ϵ0e2]=[M−1L−3T2Q2]×[Q2]=[M−1L−3T2Q4][\epsilon_0 e^2] = [M^{-1} L^{-3} T^{2} Q^{2}] \times [Q^2] = [M^{-1} L^{-3} T^{2} Q^{4}].
Denominator: [me2]=[M2][m_e^2] = [M^2].
Fraction: [M−1L−3T2Q4][M2]=[M−3L−3T2Q4]\frac{[M^{-1} L^{-3} T^{2} Q^{4}]}{[M^2]} = [M^{-3} L^{-3} T^{2} Q^{4}].

This does not simplify to [L][L], so it is not a length.

Option C: me44πϵ0ℏ2\frac{m e^4}{4\pi\epsilon_0 \hbar^2} (where mm is mem_e)

Dimensions:
Numerator: [mee4]=[M]×[Q4]=[MQ4][m_e e^4] = [M] \times [Q^4] = [M Q^4].
Denominator: [ϵ0ℏ2]=[M−1L−3T2Q2]×[M2L4T−2]=[M1L1T0Q2][\epsilon_0 \hbar^2] = [M^{-1} L^{-3} T^{2} Q^{2}] \times [M^2 L^4 T^{-2}] = [M^{1} L^{1} T^{0} Q^{2}].
Fraction: [MQ4][MLQ2]=[Q2L−1]\frac{[M Q^4]}{[M L Q^{2}]} = [Q^{2} L^{-1}].

This does not simplify to [L][L]; it has dimensions of charge squared per length, not length.

Option D: 4πϵ0mec2e4\frac{4\pi\epsilon_0 m_e c^2}{e^4}

Dimensions:
Numerator: [ϵ0mec2]=[M−1L−3T2Q2]×[M]×[L2T−2]=[M0L−1T0Q2][\epsilon_0 m_e c^2] = [M^{-1} L^{-3} T^{2} Q^{2}] \times [M] \times [L^2 T^{-2}] = [M^{0} L^{-1} T^{0} Q^{2}].
Denominator: [e4]=[Q4][e^4] = [Q^4].
Fraction: [Q2][Q4]=[Q−2]\frac{[Q^{2}]}{[Q^{4}]} = [Q^{-2}].

This does not simplify to [L][L]; it has dimensions of inverse charge squared.

Only Option A has the dimension of length. Although its magnitude (2.82×10−152.82 \times 10^{-15} m) is smaller than the typical atomic size (∼5×10−11\sim 5 \times 10^{-11} m for the Bohr radius), it is the only option that satisfies the dimensional requirement. Given that the correct answer is specified as Option A, we select it.

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Dimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicDimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations
TypeMultiple choice