RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 08 JAN S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Physics question — Dimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations

The dimension of stopping potential V0V_0 in photoelectric effect in units of Planck's constant 'h', speed of light 'c' and Gravitational constant 'G' and ampere A is:

SOLUTION

We begin by recalling that the stopping potential V0V_0 is an electric potential difference (voltage). By definition, electric potential is work per unit charge, so in fundamental dimensions it is written as

[V0]=[energy] [charge]−1=M L2 T−3 I−1.[V_0]=[ \text{energy} ]\, [\text{charge}]^{-1}=M\,L^{2}\,T^{-3}\,I^{-1}.

We have to reproduce this combination using the four given reference quantities: Planck’s constant h,h, the speed of light c,c, the universal gravitational constant G,G, and the ampere AA (which already carries the current dimension). First we write down their dimensional formulas.

1. Planck’s constant represents angular momentum or energy × time, hence [h]=M L2 T−1.[h]=M\,L^{2}\,T^{-1}.

2. The speed of light is simply a velocity, therefore [c]=L T−1.[c]=L\,T^{-1}.

3. The gravitational constant follows from Newton’s law F=Gm1m2r2.F=\dfrac{Gm_1m_2}{r^{2}}. Solving, we find [G]=M−1 L3 T−2.[G]=M^{-1}\,L^{3}\,T^{-2}.

4. The ampere already carries the unit of current, so [A]=I.[A]=I.

Next, we assume that the required combination is h x c y G z A w,h^{\,x}\,c^{\,y}\,G^{\,z}\,A^{\,w}, with unknown exponents x,  y,  z,  wx,\;y,\;z,\;w to be determined. Multiplying the dimensions of each factor, we obtain the overall dimensional product:

[h x]=Mx L2x T−x,[c y]=Ly T−y,[G z]=M−z L3z T−2z,[A w]=I w.\begin{aligned} [h^{\,x}] &= M^{x}\,L^{2x}\,T^{-x},\\[2pt] [c^{\,y}] &= L^{y}\,T^{-y},\\[2pt] [G^{\,z}] &= M^{-z}\,L^{3z}\,T^{-2z},\\[2pt] [A^{\,w}] &= I^{\,w}. \end{aligned}

Combining the corresponding powers of each fundamental dimension gives

M x−z L 2x+y+3z T (−x−y−2z) I w.M^{\,x-z}\,L^{\,2x+y+3z}\,T^{\,(-x-y-2z)}\,I^{\,w}.

We now equate the exponents of each basic dimension with those required for a potential M1 L2 T−3 I−1.M^{1}\,L^{2}\,T^{-3}\,I^{-1}. Hence we write the system of equations

Mass:  x−z=1,Length:  2x+y+3z=2,Time:  −x−y−2z=−3,Current:  w=−1.\begin{aligned} \text{Mass:}\;&x-z &=& 1,\\ \text{Length:}\;&2x+y+3z &=& 2,\\ \text{Time:}\;&-x-y-2z &=& -3,\\ \text{Current:}\;&w &=& -1. \end{aligned}

From the mass equation x−z=1x-z=1 we find z=x−1.z=x-1.

Substituting this into the length equation,

2x+y+3(x−1)=2  ⟹  5x+y−3=2  ⟹  5x+y=5,2x+y+3(x-1)=2 \;\Longrightarrow\; 5x+y-3=2 \;\Longrightarrow\; 5x+y=5, which rearranges to y=5−5x.y=5-5x.

Now we use the time equation. Replacing yy and zz with the expressions just obtained,

−x−(5−5x)−2 (x−1)=−3.-x-\bigl(5-5x\bigr)-2\,(x-1)=-3.

Simplifying step by step,

−x−5+5x−2x+2=−3,-x-5+5x-2x+2=-3, (−x+5x−2x)=2x,(−5+2)=−3,(-x+5x-2x)=2x,\qquad(-5+2)=-3, so

2x−3=−3.2x-3=-3.

Adding 3 to both sides gives 2x=0  ⟹  x=0.2x=0\;\Longrightarrow\;x=0.

Immediately, z=x−1=0−1=−1,z=x-1=0-1=-1, and y=5−5x=5−0=5.y=5-5x=5-0=5.

Finally, from the current equation we already have w=−1.w=-1.

Collecting all exponents, the required dimensional combination is

h0 c5 G−1 A−1.h^{0}\,c^{5}\,G^{-1}\,A^{-1}.

Because h0=1,h^{0}=1, this result exactly matches Option B.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Dimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicDimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations
TypeMultiple choice