RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 05 SEP S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Physics question — Dimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations

The quantities x=1μ0ε0x = \frac{1}{\sqrt{\mu_0 \varepsilon_0}}, y=EBy = \frac{E}{B} and z=lCRz = \frac{l}{CR} are defined where C-capacitance, R-Resistance, ll-length, E-Electric field, B-magnetic field and ε0\varepsilon_0, μ0\mu_0 - free space permittivity and permeability respectively. Then:

SOLUTION

First we recall the symbols for the fundamental (base) dimensions that we will use throughout the solution:

[M]  for  mass,[L]  for  length,[T]  for  time,[I]  for  electric  current.[M] \;{\rm for\; mass},\qquad [L] \;{\rm for\; length},\qquad [T] \;{\rm for\; time},\qquad [I] \;{\rm for\; electric\; current}.$

We now determine the dimensions of the two electromagnetic constants that occur in the question.

For the permeability of free space we start from the defining relation B  =  μ0 H.B \;=\; \mu_0\,H. Here BB is the magnetic flux density and HH is the magnetic field intensity. In SI units BB (tesla) has the dimension [B]  =  forcecurrent×length  =  [M L T−2][I] [L]  =  [M T−2 I−1],[B] \;=\; \frac{{\rm force}}{{\rm current}\times{\rm length}} \;=\; \frac{[M\,L\,T^{-2}]}{[I]\,[L]} \;=\; [M\,T^{-2}\,I^{-1}],$ and HH (ampere per metre) has the dimension [H]  =  [I L−1].[H]\;=\;[I\,L^{-1}]. Therefore [μ0]  =  [B][H]  =  [M T−2 I−1][I L−1]  =  [M L T−2 I−2].[\mu_0] \;=\; \frac{[B]}{[H]} \;=\; \frac{[M\,T^{-2}\,I^{-1}]}{[I\,L^{-1}]} \;=\; [M\,L\,T^{-2}\,I^{-2}].$

For the permittivity of free space we employ Coulomb’s law F  =  14πε0 q1q2r2,F \;=\; \frac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_0}\,\frac{q_1q_2}{r^2}, so that ε0  =  q1q24π F r2.\varepsilon_0 \;=\; \frac{q_1q_2}{4\pi\,F\,r^2}. Ignoring numerical constants, its dimension is [ε0]  =  [Q]2[M L T−2] [L]2  =  [I2 T2][M L3 T−2]  =  [M−1 L−3 T4 I2].[\varepsilon_0] \;=\; \frac{[Q]^2}{[M\,L\,T^{-2}]\,[L]^2} \;=\; \frac{[I^2\,T^2]}{[M\,L^3\,T^{-2}]} \;=\; [M^{-1}\,L^{-3}\,T^{4}\,I^{2}].$

With these preliminaries completed, we are ready to analyse each of the three given quantities.

1. Dimension of x=1μ0ε0.x=\dfrac{1}{\sqrt{\mu_0\varepsilon_0}}.

First multiply the dimensions of μ0\mu_0 and ε0\varepsilon_0:

[μ0ε0]  =  [M L T−2 I−2]×[M−1 L−3 T4 I2]  =  L(1−3) T(−2+4) M(1−1) I(−2+2)  =  [L−2 T2].[\mu_0\varepsilon_0] \;=\;[M\,L\,T^{-2}\,I^{-2}]\times[M^{-1}\,L^{-3}\,T^{4}\,I^{2}] \;=\;L^{(1-3)}\,T^{(-2+4)}\,M^{(1-1)}\,I^{(-2+2)} \;=\;[L^{-2}\,T^{2}].$

The square root of this product therefore has the dimension

[μ0ε0]  =  [L−1 T1].\sqrt{[\mu_0\varepsilon_0]} \;=\;[L^{-1}\,T^{1}].

Because xx is the reciprocal of that square root, we invert the above result:

[x]  =  1[L−1 T1]  =  [L1 T−1].[x]\;=\;\frac{1}{[L^{-1}\,T^{1}]}\;=\;[L^{1}\,T^{-1}].

This is exactly the dimension of speed (length per time).

2. Dimension of y=EB.y=\dfrac{E}{B}.

We already know [B]=[M T−2 I−1].[B]=[M\,T^{-2}\,I^{-1}]. Let us now find [E][E], the electric field intensity. By definition E  =  forcecharge,E \;=\; \frac{\text{force}}{\text{charge}}, so [E]  =  [M L T−2][I T]  =  [M L T−3 I−1].[E] \;=\;\frac{[M\,L\,T^{-2}]}{[I\,T]} \;=\;[M\,L\,T^{-3}\,I^{-1}].$

Dividing EE by BB gives

[y]  =  [M L T−3 I−1][M T−2 I−1]  =  [L T−1].[y] \;=\;\frac{[M\,L\,T^{-3}\,I^{-1}]}{[M\,T^{-2}\,I^{-1}]} \;=\;[L\,T^{-1}].$

Thus yy also has the dimension of speed.

3. Dimension of z=lC R.z=\dfrac{l}{C\,R}.

The length ll has the obvious dimension [l]=[L].[l]=[L].

For the capacitance CC we use the definition C  =  QV,C \;=\; \frac{Q}{V}, and voltage (potential difference) satisfies V  =  workcharge  =  [M L2 T−2][I T]  =  [M L2 T−3 I−1].V \;=\; \frac{\text{work}}{\text{charge}} \;=\; \frac{[M\,L^{2}\,T^{-2}]}{[I\,T]} \;=\;[M\,L^{2}\,T^{-3}\,I^{-1}].$ Hence

[C]  =  [I T][M L2 T−3 I−1]  =  [M−1 L−2 T4 I2].[C] \;=\;\frac{[I\,T]}{[M\,L^{2}\,T^{-3}\,I^{-1}]} \;=\;[M^{-1}\,L^{-2}\,T^{4}\,I^{2}].$

For resistance RR, Ohm’s law gives R=V/I,R = V/I, so

[R]  =  [M L2 T−3 I−1][I]  =  [M L2 T−3 I−2].[R] \;=\;\frac{[M\,L^{2}\,T^{-3}\,I^{-1}]}{[I]} \;=\;[M\,L^{2}\,T^{-3}\,I^{-2}].$

The product C RC\,R therefore possesses the dimension

[C R]  =  [M−1 L−2 T4 I2]×[M L2 T−3 I−2]  =  L(−2+2) T(4−3) M(−1+1) I(2−2)  =  [T1].[C\,R] \;=\;[M^{-1}\,L^{-2}\,T^{4}\,I^{2}] \times[M\,L^{2}\,T^{-3}\,I^{-2}] \;=\;L^{(-2+2)}\,T^{(4-3)}\,M^{(-1+1)}\,I^{(2-2)} \;=\;[T^{1}].$

Finally, dividing the length ll by this product yields

[z]  =  [L][T]  =  [L T−1].[z] \;=\;\frac{[L]}{[T]} \;=\;[L\,T^{-1}].

Thus zz again has the dimension of speed.

We have shown that

[x]=[L T−1],[y]=[L T−1],[z]=[L T−1].[x]=[L\,T^{-1}],\qquad [y]=[L\,T^{-1}],\qquad [z]=[L\,T^{-1}].$

All three quantities share the identical dimension (that of velocity).

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Dimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicDimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations
TypeMultiple choice