RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 05 SEP S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Physics question — Errors in measurement and significant figures

A physical quantity zz depends on four observables aa, bb, cc and dd, as z=a2b2/3cd3z = \frac{a^2 b^{2/3}}{\sqrt{cd^3}}. The percentage of error in the measurement of aa, bb, cc and dd are 2%2\%, 1.5%1.5\%, 4%4\% and 2.5%2.5\% respectively. The percentage of error in zz is:

SOLUTION

We have the physical quantity zz expressed as

z  =  a2 b 2/3c d3z \;=\; \frac{a^{2}\,b^{\,2/3}}{\sqrt{c}\,d^{3}}

(the square-root sign acts only on cc, while d3d^{3} is outside the root).

In error analysis we use the general rule: if a quantity can be written in the form

z  =  a m b n c p d q,z \;=\; a^{\,m}\,b^{\,n}\,c^{\,p}\,d^{\,q},

then the fractional (relative) error in zz is obtained from

Δzz=  ∣m∣ Δaa+  ∣n∣ Δbb+  ∣p∣ Δcc+  ∣q∣ Δdd.\frac{\Delta z}{z} =\; |m|\,\frac{\Delta a}{a} +\; |n|\,\frac{\Delta b}{b} +\; |p|\,\frac{\Delta c}{c} +\; |q|\,\frac{\Delta d}{d}.

This formula is nothing but the differential form of the logarithmic derivative ln⁡z=mln⁡a+nln⁡b+pln⁡c+qln⁡d\ln z = m\ln a + n\ln b + p\ln c + q\ln d with all magnitudes taken positive because every separate error contributes additively to the maximum possible error.

Comparing the given expression with the standard form we read off the exponents directly:

m=2,n=23,p=−12,q=−3.m = 2,\qquad n = \frac23,\qquad p = -\frac12,\qquad q = -3.

Only the absolute values of these exponents matter for the percentage error, so we write

∣m∣=2,∣n∣=23,∣p∣=12,∣q∣=3.|m| = 2,\qquad |n| = \frac23,\qquad |p| = \frac12,\qquad |q| = 3.

The stated percentage errors in the measured quantities are

Δaa×100=2%,  Δbb×100=1.5%,  Δcc×100=4%,  Δdd×100=2.5%.\frac{\Delta a}{a}\times100 = 2\%,\; \frac{\Delta b}{b}\times100 = 1.5\%,\; \frac{\Delta c}{c}\times100 = 4\%,\; \frac{\Delta d}{d}\times100 = 2.5\%.

Substituting these numbers into the error-propagation formula gives the percentage error in zz:

Δzz×100=2 (2%)+(23)(1.5%)+(12)(4%)+3 (2.5%).\frac{\Delta z}{z}\times100 = 2\,(2\%) + \left(\frac23\right)(1.5\%) + \left(\frac12\right)(4\%) + 3\,(2.5\%).

Now we carry out every multiplication one by one:

2 (2%)=4%,(23)(1.5%)=1%,(12)(4%)=2%,3 (2.5%)=7.5%.2\,(2\%) = 4\%, \\ \left(\frac23\right)(1.5\%) = 1\%, \\ \left(\frac12\right)(4\%) = 2\%, \\ 3\,(2.5\%) = 7.5\%.

Adding all these individual contributions we obtain

Δzz×100=4%+1%+2%+7.5%=14.5%.\frac{\Delta z}{z}\times100 = 4\% + 1\% + 2\% + 7.5\% = 14.5\%.

So the percentage error in the calculated value of zz is 14.5%14.5\%.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Errors in measurement and significant figures. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicErrors in measurement and significant figures
TypeMultiple choice