RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 04 SEP S2+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Physics question — Dimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations

A quantity xx is given by (1Fv2/WL4)(1Fv^2/WL^4) in terms of moment of inertia II, force FF, velocity vv, work WW and length LL. The dimensional formula for xx is same as that of:

SOLUTION

We are told that the physical quantity xx is expressed as

x=I F v2W L4x=\dfrac{I\,F\,v^{2}}{W\,L^{4}}

where the symbols have the following usual meanings:

I=I= moment of inertia,   F=F= force,   v=v= velocity,   W=W= work,   L=L= length.

Our task is to obtain the dimensional formula of xx and then compare it with the dimensions of the physical quantities listed in the options.

First, we write down the standard dimensional formulas (using [M][M] for mass, [L][L] for length and [T][T] for time):

• Moment of inertia II is mass × length2^{2}, so [I]=[M1L2T0][I]=[M^{1}L^{2}T^{0}].

• Force FF follows Newton’s second law F=maF=ma, giving [F]=[M1L1T−2][F]=[M^{1}L^{1}T^{-2}].

• Velocity vv is length per time, therefore [v]=[M0L1T−1][v]=[M^{0}L^{1}T^{-1}]. Consequently [v2]=[M0L2T−2][v^{2}]=[M^{0}L^{2}T^{-2}].

• Work WW equals force × displacement, hence [W]=[M1L2T−2][W]=[M^{1}L^{2}T^{-2}].

• Length LL of course has [L]=[M0L1T0][L]=[M^{0}L^{1}T^{0}], so [L4]=[M0L4T0][L^{4}]=[M^{0}L^{4}T^{0}].

Now we substitute each of these into the defining expression for xx:

Numerator dimensions:

[I F v2]=[I] [F] [v2]=[M1L2T0] [M1L1T−2] [M0L2T−2].[I\,F\,v^{2}]=[I]\,[F]\,[v^{2}]= \big[M^{1}L^{2}T^{0}\big]\, \big[M^{1}L^{1}T^{-2}\big]\, \big[M^{0}L^{2}T^{-2}\big].

Multiplying the like powers of M, L, TM,\,L,\,T one by one, we obtain

• For mass: M1×M1×M0=M2M^{1}\times M^{1}\times M^{0}=M^{2},

• For length: L2×L1×L2=L5L^{2}\times L^{1}\times L^{2}=L^{5},

• For time: T0×T−2×T−2=T−4T^{0}\times T^{-2}\times T^{-2}=T^{-4}.

So, [I F v2]=[M2L5T−4][I\,F\,v^{2}]=[M^{2}L^{5}T^{-4}].

Denominator dimensions:

[W L4]=[W] [L4]=[M1L2T−2] [M0L4T0]=[M1L6T−2].[W\,L^{4}]=[W]\,[L^{4}]= \big[M^{1}L^{2}T^{-2}\big]\, \big[M^{0}L^{4}T^{0}\big] = [M^{1}L^{6}T^{-2}].

We now divide the numerator by the denominator to get the dimensions of xx:

[x]=[M2L5T−4][M1L6T−2].[x]=\dfrac{[M^{2}L^{5}T^{-4}]}{[M^{1}L^{6}T^{-2}]}.

Carrying out the division term by term, we subtract the powers:

• Mass exponent: 2−1=1  ⇒  M1,2-1=1 \;\Rightarrow\; M^{1},

• Length exponent: 5−6=−1  ⇒  L−1,5-6=-1 \;\Rightarrow\; L^{-1},

• Time exponent: −4−(−2)=−2  ⇒  T−2.-4-(-2)=-2 \;\Rightarrow\; T^{-2}.

Hence, [x]=[M1L−1T−2].[x]=[M^{1}L^{-1}T^{-2}].

Finally, we match this result with the dimensions of the quantities in the options:

(A) Planck’s constant hh has [M1L2T−1][M^{1}L^{2}T^{-1}] - does not match.

(B) Force constant (spring constant k=F/ΔLk=F/\Delta L) has [M1T−2][M^{1}T^{-2}] - does not match.

(C) Energy density (energy per unit volume) is energyvolume\dfrac{\text{energy}}{\text{volume}}.

The dimensional formula of energy is [M1L2T−2][M^{1}L^{2}T^{-2}] and of volume is [L3][L^{3}]. Therefore

[M1L2T−2][L3]=[M1L−1T−2],\dfrac{[M^{1}L^{2}T^{-2}]}{[L^{3}]}=[M^{1}L^{-1}T^{-2}],

which exactly matches [x][x].

(D) Coefficient of viscosity η\eta has [M1L−1T−1][M^{1}L^{-1}T^{-1}] - does not match.

So the only option with the same dimensional formula as xx is energy density.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Dimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicDimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations
TypeMultiple choice