RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2021 · 31 AUG S1+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2021 Physics question — Dimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations

Which of the following equations is dimensionally incorrect?
Where tt = time, hh = height, ss = surface tension, θ\theta = angle, ρ\rho = density, a,ra, r = radius, gg = the acceleration due to gravity, VV = volume, pp = pressure, WW = work done, τ\tau = torque, ϵ\epsilon = permittivity, EE = electric field, JJ = current density, LL = length.

SOLUTION

To decide which relation is wrong we compare the dimensions on the left-hand side (LHS) with those on the right-hand side (RHS). If they differ, the equation is dimensionally incorrect.

First we tabulate the dimensions (in fundamental symbols MM for mass, LL for length, TT for time and AA for electric current).

Work (W):  force×distance=(MLT−2) (L)=ML2T−2Torque (τ):  force×distance=ML2T−2Pressure (p):  force/area=ML−1T−2Surface tension (s):  force/length=MT−2Density (ρ):  ML−3Acceleration (g):  LT−2Viscosity (η):  ML−1T−1Volume (V):  L3Current density (J):  AL−2Electric field (E):  MLT−3A−1Permittivity (ϵ):  M−1L−3T4A2\begin{aligned} \text{Work }(W)&:&\; \text{force}\times\text{distance}= (MLT^{-2})\,(L)=ML^{2}T^{-2}\\ \text{Torque }(\tau)&:&\; \text{force}\times\text{distance}=ML^{2}T^{-2}\\ \text{Pressure }(p)&:&\; \text{force}/\text{area}=ML^{-1}T^{-2}\\ \text{Surface tension }(s)&:&\; \text{force}/\text{length}=MT^{-2}\\ \text{Density }(\rho)&:&\; ML^{-3}\\ \text{Acceleration }(g)&:&\; LT^{-2}\\ \text{Viscosity }(\eta)&:&\; ML^{-1}T^{-1}\\ \text{Volume }(V)&:&\; L^{3}\\ \text{Current density }(J)&:&\; AL^{-2}\\ \text{Electric field }(E)&:&\; MLT^{-3}A^{-1}\\ \text{Permittivity }(\epsilon)&:&\; M^{-1}L^{-3}T^{4}A^{2} \end{aligned} Length (a,r,h,L)(a,r,h,L) has dimension LL, the angle θ\theta is dimensionless.

Option A gives W=τθW=\tau\theta.

LHS →\rightarrow W:ML2T−2W:ML^{2}T^{-2}.

RHS →\rightarrow τθ=(ML2T−2)(1)=ML2T−2\tau\theta=(ML^{2}T^{-2})(1)=ML^{2}T^{-2} because θ\theta is dimensionless.

The two sides match, so Option A is dimensionally correct.

Option B gives V=πpa48ηLV=\dfrac{\pi p a^{4}}{8\eta L}.

LHS →\rightarrow V:L3V:L^{3}.

RHS step by step:

We have p a4p\,a^{4} with dimensions (ML−1T−2) (L4)=ML3T−2.\bigl(ML^{-1}T^{-2}\bigr)\,(L^{4}) = ML^{3}T^{-2}.

We divide by ηL\eta L whose dimensions are (ML−1T−1) (L)=MT−1.\bigl(ML^{-1}T^{-1}\bigr)\,(L)=MT^{-1}.

Therefore p a4ηL:  ML3T−2MT−1=ML3T−2M T1=L3T−1.\dfrac{p\,a^{4}}{\eta L}:\; \dfrac{ML^{3}T^{-2}}{MT^{-1}} =\dfrac{ML^{3}T^{-2}}{M}\,T^{1} =L^{3}T^{-1}.

So the RHS carries an extra factor T−1T^{-1} and has dimension L3T−1L^{3}T^{-1}, whereas the LHS is only L3L^{3}. They differ, making this relation dimensionally inconsistent.

Option C gives h=2scos⁡θρrgh=\dfrac{2s\cos\theta}{\rho r g}.

LHS →\rightarrow h:Lh:L.

RHS numerator 2scos⁡θ2s\cos\theta has dimension MT−2MT^{-2} (since cos⁡θ\cos\theta is dimensionless).

Denominator ρrg\rho r g has dimension (ML−3) (L) (LT−2)=ML−1T−2.\bigl(ML^{-3}\bigr)\,(L)\,(LT^{-2})=ML^{-1}T^{-2}. Hence MT−2ML−1T−2=L,\dfrac{MT^{-2}}{ML^{-1}T^{-2}}=L, matching the LHS. Option C is correct.

Option D gives J=ϵ∂E∂tJ=\epsilon\dfrac{\partial E}{\partial t}.

LHS →\rightarrow J:AL−2J:AL^{-2}.

First write the time derivative: ∂E∂t:  MLT−3A−1T=MLT−4A−1.\dfrac{\partial E}{\partial t} :\; \frac{MLT^{-3}A^{-1}}{T} = MLT^{-4}A^{-1}.

Now multiply by ϵ\epsilon: ϵ∂E∂t=(M−1L−3T4A2)(MLT−4A−1)=L−2A,\epsilon\dfrac{\partial E}{\partial t} =\bigl(M^{-1}L^{-3}T^{4}A^{2}\bigr)\bigl(MLT^{-4}A^{-1}\bigr) =L^{-2}A, which is exactly AL−2AL^{-2}, so the dimensions tally. Option D is also correct.

Only Option B fails the dimensional test. Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Dimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicDimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations
TypeMultiple choice