RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 02 SEP S2+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Physics question — Dimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations

If momentum (P), area (A) and time (T) are taken to be the fundamental quantities then the dimensional formula for energy is:

SOLUTION

We know that in the usual MLT system the dimensional formula for mechanical energy (work) is [E]=[M L2 T−2][E]=[M\,L^{2}\,T^{-2}], because work is force times distance and force itself is mass times acceleration.

Now the problem tells us to treat momentum PP, area AA and time TT as the new fundamental quantities. Therefore we must rewrite the above [M L2 T−2][M\,L^{2}\,T^{-2}] in terms of PP, AA and TT only.

First we recall the standard dimensional expressions of the given fundamental quantities in the MLT system:

Momentum is defined as mass times velocity, so [P]=[M L T−1].[P]=[M\,L\,T^{-1}].

Area is the product of two lengths, hence [A]=[L2].[A]=[L^{2}].

Time is already fundamental, so [T]=[T].[T]=[T].

Let us now assume that the energy dimension can be built as a product of powers of these three fundamental quantities. We therefore write [E]=Px Ay Tz,[E]=P^{x}\,A^{y}\,T^{z}, where xx, yy and zz are the unknown exponents to be determined.

Next, we substitute the MLT expressions of PP, AA and TT into this assumed form:

[E]=(M1L1T−1)x  (L2)y  (T1)z.[E]=\bigl(M^{1}L^{1}T^{-1}\bigr)^{x}\; \bigl(L^{2}\bigr)^{y}\; \bigl(T^{1}\bigr)^{z}.$

Collecting the powers of each fundamental symbol MM, LL and TT separately, we get

[E]=M x  L x+2y  T −x+z.[E]=M^{\,x}\; L^{\,x+2y}\; T^{\,-x+z}.$

This combined exponent form must equal the original energy dimension M1L2T−2M^{1}L^{2}T^{-2}, so we equate the corresponding powers term by term:

For mass MM: x=1.x = 1.$

For length LL: x+2y=2.x + 2y = 2.$

For time TT: −x+z=−2.-x + z = -2.$

We now solve these three simple linear equations step by step.

From the first equation we immediately have x=1.x = 1.$

Substituting x=1x=1 into the second equation gives 1+2y=2⟹2y=1⟹y=12.1 + 2y = 2 \quad\Longrightarrow\quad 2y = 1 \quad\Longrightarrow\quad y = \frac{1}{2}.$

Substituting x=1x=1 into the third equation gives −1+z=−2⟹z=−1.-1 + z = -2 \quad\Longrightarrow\quad z = -1.$

Thus the required exponents are x=1,y=12,z=−1.x = 1,\qquad y = \tfrac12,\qquad z = -1.$

Putting these values back into the assumed form PxAyTzP^{x}A^{y}T^{z}, we obtain

[E]=P1 A1/2 T−1.[E]=P^{1}\,A^{1/2}\,T^{-1}.$

Therefore the dimensional formula for energy, when momentum, area and time are chosen as fundamental quantities, is written as [PA1/2T−1].[PA^{1/2}T^{-1}].

Looking at the given options, this matches Option C.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Dimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicDimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations
TypeMultiple choice