RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 02 SEP S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Physics question — Dimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations

If speed V, area A and force F are chosen as fundamental units, then the dimension of Young's modulus will be:

SOLUTION

We know that Young’s modulus YY is defined as the ratio of stress to strain. Because strain is a pure number (dimensionless), the dimension of YY is the same as the dimension of stress.

First, let us recall that stress is force per unit area, so

Stress=ForceArea.\text{Stress}=\dfrac{\text{Force}}{\text{Area}}.

In the ordinary M ⁣L ⁣TM\!L\!T (mass-length-time) system the dimensional formula of force is M L T−2,M\,L\,T^{-2}, while the dimensional formula of area is L2.L^{2}. Therefore, the dimensional formula of Young’s modulus in the M ⁣L ⁣TM\!L\!T system becomes

[Y]=M L T−2L2=M L−1 T−2.[Y]=\dfrac{M\,L\,T^{-2}}{L^{2}}=M\,L^{-1}\,T^{-2}.

Now the question asks us to re-express this same quantity using a new set of fundamental units: speed V,V, area AA and force F.F. We write the unknown dimensional formula as

[Y]=F a A b V c,[Y]=F^{\,a}\,A^{\,b}\,V^{\,c},

where a, b, ca,\,b,\,c are the exponents we must determine.

Next we translate each new fundamental unit back into the familiar M ⁣L ⁣TM\!L\!T language:

[F]=M L T−2,[A]=L2,[V]=L T−1.[F]=M\,L\,T^{-2},\qquad [A]=L^{2},\qquad [V]=L\,T^{-1}.

Substituting these into F a A b V cF^{\,a}\,A^{\,b}\,V^{\,c} gives

F a A b V c=(M L T−2)a(L2)b(L T−1)c=Ma L a+2b+c T−2a−c.F^{\,a}\,A^{\,b}\,V^{\,c}=\left(M\,L\,T^{-2}\right)^{a}\left(L^{2}\right)^{b}\left(L\,T^{-1}\right)^{c}=M^{a}\,L^{\,a+2b+c}\,T^{-2a-c}.

This result must match the already known M ⁣L ⁣TM\!L\!T exponents of Young’s modulus, namely M1 L−1 T−2.M^{1}\,L^{-1}\,T^{-2}. Hence we equate exponents term by term:

Mass exponent: a=1.a=1.(1)

Length exponent: a+2b+c=−1.a+2b+c=-1.(2)

Time exponent: −2a−c=−2.-2a-c=-2.(3)

Using equation (1) a=1a=1 inside equation (3) gives

−2(1)−c=−2    ⟹    −2−c=−2    ⟹    c=0.-2(1)-c=-2\;\;\Longrightarrow\;\;-2-c=-2\;\;\Longrightarrow\;\;c=0.

With a=1a=1 and c=0,c=0, substitute into equation (2):

1+2b+0=−1    ⟹    2b=−2    ⟹    b=−1.1+2b+0=-1\;\;\Longrightarrow\;\;2b=-2\;\;\Longrightarrow\;\;b=-1.

Thus we have determined

a=1,b=−1,c=0.a=1,\qquad b=-1,\qquad c=0.

Putting these values back, the dimensional formula of Young’s modulus in the F ⁣A ⁣VF\!A\!V system is

[Y]=F1 A−1 V0=F A−1.[Y]=F^{1}\,A^{-1}\,V^{0}=F\,A^{-1}.

This matches option D, which is written as FA−1V0.FA^{-1}V^{0}.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Dimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicDimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations
TypeMultiple choice