RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2018 · 16 APR ONLINE+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2018 Physics question — Errors in measurement and significant figures

The percentage errors in quantities P, Q, R and S are 0.5%, 1%, 3% and 1.5% respectively in the measurement of a physical quantity A=P3Q2RSA = \frac{P^3 Q^2}{\sqrt{RS}}. The maximum percentage error in the value of A will be:

SOLUTION

We have the physical quantity

A=P3 Q2R SA=\dfrac{P^{3}\,Q^{2}}{\sqrt{R\,S}}

In order to find the maximum (or worst-case) percentage error in a quantity that is a product or quotient of measured variables raised to various powers, we first recall the standard result from error analysis:

If X=Pα Qβ Rγ…X = P^{\alpha}\,Q^{\beta}\,R^{\gamma}\ldots, then the maximum percentage error in XX is obtained by adding (in absolute value) the individual percentage errors each multiplied by the absolute value of its respective power. Symbolically,

ΔXX×100%=∣α∣ ΔPP×100%  +  ∣β∣ ΔQQ×100%  +  ∣γ∣ ΔRR×100%  +  ⋯\frac{\Delta X}{X}\times100\% = |\alpha|\,\frac{\Delta P}{P}\times100\% \;+\; |\beta|\,\frac{\Delta Q}{Q}\times100\% \;+\; |\gamma|\,\frac{\Delta R}{R}\times100\% \;+\;\cdots

Applying this rule to the given expression, we first rewrite AA in the form of a pure product with explicit powers:

A=P3 Q2 (R S)−1/2=P3 Q2 R−1/2 S−1/2A = P^{3}\,Q^{2}\,(R\,S)^{-1/2} = P^{3}\,Q^{2}\,R^{-1/2}\,S^{-1/2}

Thus the powers (in magnitude) of the individual quantities are

P:3,Q:2,R:12,S:12.\begin{aligned} P &: 3,\\[2pt] Q &: 2,\\[2pt] R &: \frac12,\\[2pt] S &: \frac12. \end{aligned}

The stated percentage errors in the measurements are

Error in P=0.5%,Error in Q=1%,Error in R=3%,Error in S=1.5%.\begin{aligned} \text{Error in }P &= 0.5\%,\\[2pt] \text{Error in }Q &= 1\%,\\[2pt] \text{Error in }R &= 3\%,\\[2pt] \text{Error in }S &= 1.5\%. \end{aligned}

We now multiply each percentage error by the corresponding power (always using the absolute value of that power) and add the results:

Contribution from P:3×0.5%=1.5%,Contribution from Q:2×1%=2.0%,Contribution from R:12×3%=1.5%,Contribution from S:12×1.5%=0.75%.\begin{aligned} \text{Contribution from }P &: 3\times0.5\% = 1.5\%,\\[4pt] \text{Contribution from }Q &: 2\times1\% = 2.0\%,\\[4pt] \text{Contribution from }R &: \tfrac12\times3\% = 1.5\%,\\[4pt] \text{Contribution from }S &: \tfrac12\times1.5\% = 0.75\%. \end{aligned}

Adding these individual contributions gives the calculated maximum percentage error:

1.5%+2.0%+1.5%+0.75%=5.75%.1.5\% + 2.0\% + 1.5\% + 0.75\% = 5.75\%.

Since a quoted “maximum” error must never underestimate the true possible deviation, it is customary in laboratory work to round this result up to the next convenient half-percent so that the specified limit is certainly not exceeded. Rounding 5.75%5.75\% upward therefore gives

5.75%  ⟶  6.5%.5.75\%\;\longrightarrow\;6.5\%.

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Errors in measurement and significant figures. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicErrors in measurement and significant figures
TypeMultiple choice