RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2018 · 15 APR S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2018 Physics question — Dimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations

The characteristic distance at which quantum gravitational effects are significant, the Planck length, can be determined from a suitable combination of the fundamental physical constants G, h and c. Which of the following correctly gives the Planck length?

SOLUTION

First, we recall that the Planck length ℓP\ell_P must be built only from the universal constants GG (Newton’s gravitational constant), hh (Planck’s constant) and cc (speed of light). Therefore we suppose ℓP=Gα hβ cγ\ell_P = G^{\alpha}\,h^{\beta}\,c^{\gamma} where α,  β,  γ\alpha,\;\beta,\;\gamma are real numbers to be determined by dimensional analysis.

Now we write the dimensions of each quantity in the fundamental symbols MM for mass, LL for length and TT for time:

[G]=M−1L3T−2,[h]=ML2T−1,[c]=LT−1.[G]=M^{-1}L^{3}T^{-2},\qquad [h]=ML^{2}T^{-1},\qquad [c]=LT^{-1}.

Hence the dimensions of the assumed product are

[Gαhβcγ]=M− αL3αT−2α  MβL2βT−β  LγT−γ.[G^{\alpha}h^{\beta}c^{\gamma}] = M^{-\,\alpha}L^{3\alpha}T^{-2\alpha}\; M^{\beta}L^{2\beta}T^{-\beta}\; L^{\gamma}T^{-\gamma}.

Collecting the powers of each fundamental dimension, we obtain

M− α+β  L 3α+2β+γ  T− 2α−β−γ.M^{-\,\alpha+\beta}\;L^{\,3\alpha+2\beta+\gamma}\;T^{-\,2\alpha-\beta-\gamma}.

The Planck length is, by definition, a quantity of dimension length alone, so its overall dimensions must be M0L1T0.M^{0}L^{1}T^{0}. Therefore we write three simultaneous equations by equating the exponents:

For mass: − α+β=0.-\,\alpha+\beta = 0.

For length: 3α+2β+γ=1.3\alpha + 2\beta + \gamma = 1.

For time: − 2α−β−γ=0.-\,2\alpha - \beta - \gamma = 0.

From the first equation we have β=α.\beta = \alpha. Substituting this into the time equation gives

− 2α−α−γ=0    ⇒    −3α−γ=0    ⇒    γ=−3α.-\,2\alpha - \alpha - \gamma = 0 \;\;\Rightarrow\;\; -3\alpha - \gamma = 0 \;\;\Rightarrow\;\; \gamma = -3\alpha.

Now we use these results in the length equation:

3α+2α+(−3α)=1    ⇒    2α=1    ⇒    α=12.3\alpha + 2\alpha + (-3\alpha) = 1 \;\;\Rightarrow\;\; 2\alpha = 1 \;\;\Rightarrow\;\; \alpha = \dfrac{1}{2}.

Because β=α,\beta = \alpha, we have β=12,\beta = \dfrac{1}{2}, and because γ=−3α,\gamma = -3\alpha, we have γ=−32.\gamma = -\dfrac{3}{2}.

Therefore

ℓP=G12 h12 c−32=(G hc3)12.\ell_P = G^{\frac{1}{2}}\,h^{\frac{1}{2}}\,c^{-\frac{3}{2}} = \left(\dfrac{G\,h}{c^{3}}\right)^{\frac{1}{2}}.

This expression is exactly the same as Option B.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Dimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicDimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations
TypeMultiple choice