JEE MAIN 2014 · 12 APR ONLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED
JEE Main 2014 Physics question — Dimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations
From the following combinations of physical constants (expressed through their usual symbols) the only combination, that would have the same value in different systems of units, is:
SOLUTION
To determine which combination of physical constants has the same value in different systems of units, we need to find the dimensionless quantity. A dimensionless quantity has dimensions of mass, length, time, and current all raised to the power zero, i.e., [M0L0T0I0]. We will perform dimensional analysis on each option using the following dimensions of the fundamental constants:
Speed of light, c: [LT−1]
Planck's constant, h: [ML2T−1] (since energy E=hν and ν has [T−1])
Elementary charge, e: [IT] (charge = current × time)
Gravitational constant, G: [M−1L3T−2] (from Newton's law of gravitation)
Permittivity of free space, ε0: [M−1L−3T4I2] (from Coulomb's law: F=4πε01r2q1q2)
Permeability of free space, μ0: [MLT−2I−2] (from the force between parallel currents)
Note that μ0ε0=c21, so the dimensions of μ0ε0 are [T2L−2].
Also, constants like 2π are dimensionless and do not affect the dimensional analysis.
Now, we evaluate each option:
Option A:2πε02ch
Dimensions of numerator ch:
[LT−1]×[ML2T−1]=[ML3T−2]
Dimensions of denominator ε02:
[M−1L−3T4I2]2=[M−2L−6T8I4]
Dimensions of fraction:
[M−2L−6T8I4][ML3T−2]=M1−(−2)L3−(−6)T−2−8I−4=[M3L9T−10I−4]
This is not dimensionless.
Option B:2πε0Gme2e2
Dimensions of numerator e2:
[IT]2=[I2T2]
Dimensions of denominator ε0Gme2:
ε0:[M−1L−3T4I2],
G:[M−1L3T−2],
me2:[M]2=[M2],
so ε0×G×me2=[M−1L−3T4I2]×[M−1L3T−2]×[M2]=M−1−1+2L−3+3T4−2I2=[M0L0T2I2]
Dimensions of fraction:
[T2I2][I2T2]=[I2−2T2−2]=[M0L0T0I0]
This is dimensionless.
Option C:c2μ0ε0⋅he2G
First part: c2μ0ε0,
dimensions of μ0ε0: [T2L−2],
dimensions of c2: [L2T−2],
so fraction: [L2T−2][T2L−2]=T2−(−2)L−2−2=[T4L−4]
Second part: he2G,
dimensions of G: [M−1L3T−2],
dimensions of he2: h:[ML2T−1], e2:[I2T2], so he2=[ML2T−1]×[I2T2]=[ML2TI2],
fraction: [ML2TI2][M−1L3T−2]=M−1−1L3−2T−2−1I−2=[M−2LT−3I−2]