RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 11 JAN S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Physics question — Dimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations

If speed (V), acceleration (A) and force (F) are considered as fundamental units, the dimension of Young's modulus will be:

SOLUTION

We begin by recalling the basic definition: Young’s modulus YY equals the ratio of normal stress to longitudinal strain. Since strain is dimensionless, the dimension of YY is the same as that of stress, that is, force per unit area.

So, in the ordinary M ⁣L ⁣TM\!L\!T system we would write

[Y]=[F][A]=MLT−2L2=ML−1T−2.[Y]=\dfrac{[F]}{[A]}=\dfrac{M L T^{-2}}{L^{2}}=M L^{-1} T^{-2}.

However, in the present problem the fundamental (independent) quantities are not M,  L,  TM,\;L,\;T but

• speed VV    (V=L T−1V=L\,T^{-1}),
• acceleration AA    (A=L T−2A=L\,T^{-2}),
• force FF    (F=M L T−2F=M\,L\,T^{-2}).

We must therefore express the dimension ML−1T−2M L^{-1} T^{-2} in the form

Vα Aβ Fγ.V^{\alpha}\,A^{\beta}\,F^{\gamma}.

First we translate each of the three fundamental quantities into M,  L,  TM,\;L,\;T exponents:

Vα=LαT−α,V^{\alpha}=L^{\alpha}T^{-\alpha},
Aβ=LβT−2β,A^{\beta}=L^{\beta}T^{-2\beta},
Fγ=MγLγT−2γ.F^{\gamma}=M^{\gamma}L^{\gamma}T^{-2\gamma}.

Multiplying these three contributions, the overall exponents of M,  L,  TM,\;L,\;T become

M: γ,M:\ \gamma,
L: α+β+γ,L:\ \alpha+\beta+\gamma,
T: −α−2β−2γ.T:\ -\alpha-2\beta-2\gamma.

We must equate these to the target exponents in M1L−1T−2M^{1}L^{-1}T^{-2}. Hence the system of algebraic equations is

γ=1,\gamma = 1,
α+β+γ=−1,\alpha+\beta+\gamma = -1,
−α−2β−2γ=−2.-\alpha-2\beta-2\gamma = -2.

Substituting γ=1\gamma=1 into the second equation gives

α+β+1=−1    ⟹    α+β=−2.\alpha+\beta+1=-1\;\;\Longrightarrow\;\;\alpha+\beta=-2.

Substituting γ=1\gamma=1 into the third equation yields

−α−2β−2=−2    ⟹    −α−2β=0    ⟹    α+2β=0.-\alpha-2\beta-2=-2\;\;\Longrightarrow\;\;-\alpha-2\beta=0\;\;\Longrightarrow\;\;\alpha+2\beta=0.

We now solve the simultaneous equations

α+β=−2,\alpha+\beta=-2,
α+2β=0.\alpha+2\beta=0.

Subtracting the first from the second gives

(α+2β)−(α+β)=0−(−2)    ⟹    β=2.(\alpha+2\beta)-(\alpha+\beta)=0-(-2)\;\;\Longrightarrow\;\;\beta=2.

Substituting β=2\beta=2 back into α+β=−2\alpha+\beta=-2 gives

α+2=−2    ⟹    α=−4.\alpha+2=-2\;\;\Longrightarrow\;\;\alpha=-4.

Collecting the exponents, we have

α=−4,β=2,γ=1.\alpha=-4,\quad\beta=2,\quad\gamma=1.

Therefore the dimensional formula of Young’s modulus in terms of V,  A,  FV,\;A,\;F is

[Y]=V−4 A2 F1=V−4A2F.[Y]=V^{-4}\,A^{2}\,F^{1}=V^{-4}A^{2}F.

Among the given alternatives, this corresponds to Option D.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Dimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicDimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations
TypeMultiple choice