A beaker contains a fluid of density , specific heat and viscosity . The beaker is filled up to height h. To estimate the rate of heat transfer per unit area by convection when beaker is put on a hot plate, a student proposes that it should depend on , and when (in ) is the difference in the temperature between the bottom and top of the fluid. In that situation the correct option for is:
We are asked to find an expression for the rate of heat transfer per unit area, written as . Because this is a rate of energy flow through a unit surface, its physical dimension is that of power per unit area.
First let us write down the basic dimensions in the system:
Power has dimension (since and energy is work ). Dividing by area gives
Now we list the three quantities on which the student believes depends and write their dimensions.
1. Dynamic viscosity Formula for its dimension: Shear stress has dimension , and velocity gradient has dimension , so
2. The factor Specific heat is defined by Re-arranging, , hence where stands for temperature. Multiplying by the temperature difference removes the temperature dimension, so Dividing by height gives
3. The factor Density has dimension . Acceleration due to gravity has dimension . Hence
We now search for a product of the above three quantities, each possibly raised to some power, that reproduces . Inspection of the options shows that only direct products have been proposed, so we can test them one by one.
Option A :
Combining the dimensions we have
This exactly matches the required , so Option A is dimensionally consistent.
Option B :
This gives , which is not , so Option B is incorrect.
Option C :
First compute :
Multiplying this by from gives
which again fails to match , so Option C is incorrect.
Option D :
We already found above that its dimension is , clearly not , hence Option D is also incorrect.
Among all the choices, only Option A reproduces the correct physical dimension for heat flux. Therefore the student’s dimensional reasoning leads to
Hence, the correct answer is Option A.
Tagged Dimensional formulae of physical quantities. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.