RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2015 · 11 APR ONLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2015 Physics question — Dimensional formulae of physical quantities

A beaker contains a fluid of density ρ\rho kgm3\frac{kg}{m^3}, specific heat SS Jkg⋅∘C\frac{J}{kg \cdot ^\circ C} and viscosity η\eta. The beaker is filled up to height h. To estimate the rate of heat transfer per unit area (QA)\left(\frac{Q}{A}\right) by convection when beaker is put on a hot plate, a student proposes that it should depend on η\eta, (SΔθh)\left(\frac{S\Delta\theta}{h}\right) and (1ρg)\left(\frac{1}{\rho g}\right) when Δθ\Delta\theta (in ∘C^\circ C) is the difference in the temperature between the bottom and top of the fluid. In that situation the correct option for (QA)\left(\frac{Q}{A}\right) is:

SOLUTION

We are asked to find an expression for the rate of heat transfer per unit area, written as QA\dfrac{Q}{A}. Because this is a rate of energy flow through a unit surface, its physical dimension is that of power per unit area.

First let us write down the basic dimensions in the M  L  TM\;L\;T system:

Power PP has dimension [P]=ML2T−3[P]=M L^2 T^{-3} (since P=energytimeP=\dfrac{\text{energy}}{\text{time}} and energy is work F ⁣⋅ ⁣d=(MLT−2)LF\! \cdot\! d = (M L T^{-2})L). Dividing by area A  (=[L2])A\;(=[L^2]) gives

[QA]=ML0T−3=MT−3.\left[\dfrac{Q}{A}\right]=M L^0 T^{-3}=M T^{-3}.

Now we list the three quantities on which the student believes QA\dfrac{Q}{A} depends and write their dimensions.

1. Dynamic viscosity η\eta  Formula for its dimension: η=shear stressvelocity gradient.\eta=\dfrac{\text{shear stress}}{\text{velocity gradient}}.  Shear stress has dimension ML−1T−2M L^{-1} T^{-2}, and velocity gradient has dimension T−1T^{-1},  so [η]=ML−1T−1.[\eta]=M L^{-1} T^{-1}.

2. The factor SΔθh\dfrac{S\Delta\theta}{h}  Specific heat SS is defined by Q=mSΔθ  .Q=m S \Delta\theta \;.  Re-arranging, S=Qm ΔθS=\dfrac{Q}{m\,\Delta\theta}, hence  [S]=ML2T−2M Θ=L2T−2Θ−1,[S]=\dfrac{M L^2 T^{-2}}{M\,\Theta}=L^{2} T^{-2} \Theta^{-1},  where Θ\Theta stands for temperature.  Multiplying by the temperature difference Δθ\Delta\theta removes the temperature dimension, so  [SΔθ]=L2T−2.\left[S\Delta\theta\right]=L^{2} T^{-2}.  Dividing by height h  (=[L])h\;(=[L]) gives  [SΔθh]=LT−2.\left[\dfrac{S\Delta\theta}{h}\right]=L T^{-2}.

3. The factor 1ρg\dfrac{1}{\rho g}  Density ρ\rho has dimension ML−3M L^{-3}.  Acceleration due to gravity gg has dimension LT−2L T^{-2}.  Hence [1ρg]=1(ML−3)(LT−2)=M−1L2T2.\left[\dfrac{1}{\rho g}\right]=\dfrac{1}{(M L^{-3})(L T^{-2})}=M^{-1} L^{2} T^{2}.

We now search for a product of the above three quantities, each possibly raised to some power, that reproduces MT−3M T^{-3}. Inspection of the options shows that only direct products have been proposed, so we can test them one by one.

Option A : (SΔθh)η\left(\dfrac{S\Delta\theta}{h}\right)\eta

Combining the dimensions we have

[LT−2][ML−1T−1]=M L(1−1) T(−2−1)=M T−3.\left[L T^{-2}\right]\left[M L^{-1} T^{-1}\right] = M\,L^{(1-1)}\,T^{(-2-1)} = M\,T^{-3}.

This exactly matches the required MT−3M T^{-3}, so Option A is dimensionally consistent.

Option B : η(SΔθh)(1ρg)\eta\left(\dfrac{S\Delta\theta}{h}\right)\left(\dfrac{1}{\rho g}\right)

[ML−1T−1][LT−2][M−1L2T2]=M(1−1) L(−1+1+2) T(−1−2+2)=L2 T−1.\left[M L^{-1} T^{-1}\right] \left[L T^{-2}\right] \left[M^{-1} L^{2} T^{2}\right] = M^{(1-1)}\,L^{(-1+1+2)}\,T^{(-1-2+2)} = L^{2}\,T^{-1}.

This gives L2T−1L^{2} T^{-1}, which is not MT−3M T^{-3}, so Option B is incorrect.

Option C : (SΔθηh)(1ρg)\left(\dfrac{S\Delta\theta}{\eta h}\right)\left(\dfrac{1}{\rho g}\right)

First compute SΔθηh\dfrac{S\Delta\theta}{\eta h}:

[SΔθ][η][h]=L2T−2(ML−1T−1)(L)=L2T−2ML0T−1=M−1L2T−1.\dfrac{[S\Delta\theta]}{[\eta][h]} = \dfrac{L^{2} T^{-2}}{(M L^{-1} T^{-1})(L)} = \dfrac{L^{2} T^{-2}}{M L^{0} T^{-1}} = M^{-1} L^{2} T^{-1}.

Multiplying this by [M−1L2T2]\left[M^{-1} L^{2} T^{2}\right] from 1ρg\dfrac{1}{\rho g} gives

M−2L4T1,M^{-2} L^{4} T^{1},

which again fails to match MT−3M T^{-3}, so Option C is incorrect.

Option D : SΔθηh\dfrac{S\Delta\theta}{\eta h}

We already found above that its dimension is M−1L2T−1M^{-1} L^{2} T^{-1}, clearly not MT−3M T^{-3}, hence Option D is also incorrect.

Among all the choices, only Option A reproduces the correct physical dimension for heat flux. Therefore the student’s dimensional reasoning leads to

QA  =  η(SΔθh).\dfrac{Q}{A}\;=\;\eta\left(\dfrac{S\Delta\theta}{h}\right).

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Dimensional formulae of physical quantities. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicDimensional formulae of physical quantities
TypeMultiple choice