RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 10 APR S2+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Physics question — Dimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations

In the formula X = 5YZ2^2, X and Z have dimensions of capacitance and magnetic field, respectively. What are the dimensions of Y in SI units?

SOLUTION

We have the dimensional equation X=5 Y Z2X = 5\,Y\,Z^{2}. The numeral 5 is dimensionless, so the dimensions of the physical quantities must satisfy

[X]=[Y] [Z]2 .[X] = [Y]\,[Z]^{2}\,.

Hence, to find the dimensions of YY we need [Y]=[X][Z]2.[Y] = \dfrac{[X]}{[Z]^{2}}.

Step 1 - Dimensions of XX (Capacitance)
Capacitance CC is defined by the relation C=QVC = \dfrac{Q}{V}, where QQ is electric charge and VV is potential difference.

The dimension of charge is current × time: [Q]=A T.[Q] = A\,T.

Voltage is work per unit charge: V=WQ.V = \dfrac{W}{Q}. Work (or energy) has the dimensions of M L2 T−2M\,L^{2}\,T^{-2}, so

[V]=M L2 T−2A T=M L2 T−3 A−1 .[V] = \dfrac{M\,L^{2}\,T^{-2}}{A\,T} = M\,L^{2}\,T^{-3}\,A^{-1}\,.

Therefore, the dimensional formula of capacitance is

[C]=A TM L2 T−3 A−1=M−1 L−2 T4 A2 .[C] = \dfrac{A\,T}{M\,L^{2}\,T^{-3}\,A^{-1}} = M^{-1}\,L^{-2}\,T^{4}\,A^{2}\,.

Since XX has the dimensions of capacitance, we write

[X]=M−1 L−2 T4 A2 .[X] = M^{-1}\,L^{-2}\,T^{4}\,A^{2}\,.

Step 2 - Dimensions of ZZ (Magnetic field)
Magnetic field BB is defined through the Lorentz force F=q v BF = q\,v\,B on a moving charge. Rearranging, B=Fq v.B = \dfrac{F}{q\,v}.

The force dimension is [F]=M L T−2 ,[F] = M\,L\,T^{-2}\,, charge is [q]=A T ,[q] = A\,T\,, and speed is [v]=L T−1 .[v] = L\,T^{-1}\,. Therefore

[B]=M L T−2A T ⋅ L T−1=M L T−2A L=M T−2 A−1 .[B] = \dfrac{M\,L\,T^{-2}}{A\,T \, \cdot \, L\,T^{-1}} = \dfrac{M\,L\,T^{-2}}{A\,L} = M\,T^{-2}\,A^{-1}\,.

This is the dimensional formula of a magnetic field (tesla). Thus

[Z]=M T−2 A−1 .[Z] = M\,T^{-2}\,A^{-1}\,.

Step 3 - Square of ZZ and its inverse

Squaring ZZ gives

[Z]2=(M T−2 A−1)2=M2 T−4 A−2 .[Z]^{2} = (M\,T^{-2}\,A^{-1})^{2} = M^{2}\,T^{-4}\,A^{-2}\,.

The reciprocal of this quantity, which we need for 1[Z]2\dfrac{1}{[Z]^{2}}, is

[Z]−2=M−2 T4 A2 .[Z]^{-2} = M^{-2}\,T^{4}\,A^{2}\,.

Step 4 - Dimensions of YY

Now substitute the results into [Y]=[X][Z]2[Y] = \dfrac{[X]}{[Z]^{2}}:

[Y]=(M−1 L−2 T4 A2)×(M−2 T4 A2).[Y] = (M^{-1}\,L^{-2}\,T^{4}\,A^{2}) \times (M^{-2}\,T^{4}\,A^{2}).

Combine the powers of each fundamental unit:

Mass: (−1)+(−2)=−3,(-1) + (-2) = -3,

Length: (−2)+0=−2,(-2) + 0 = -2,

Time: 4+4=8,4 + 4 = 8,

Current: 2+2=4.2 + 2 = 4.

Thus

[Y]=M−3 L−2 T8 A4 .[Y] = M^{-3}\,L^{-2}\,T^{8}\,A^{4}\,.

Comparing with the given options, this matches Option D.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Dimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicDimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations
TypeMultiple choice