RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2016 · 10 APR ONLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2016 Physics question — Dimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations

AA, BB, CC, and DD are four different physical quantities having different dimensions. None of them is dimensionless. But we know that the equation AD=Cln⁡(BD)AD = C\ln(BD) holds true. Then which of the combination is not a meaningful quantity?

SOLUTION

Given that AA, BB, CC, and DD are four different physical quantities with different dimensions and none is dimensionless, and the equation AD=Cln⁡(BD)AD = C \ln(BD) holds true. For this equation to be dimensionally consistent, the argument of the logarithm must be dimensionless. Therefore, BDBD must be dimensionless, which implies [B][D]=1[B][D] = 1, so [B]=[D]−1[B] = [D]^{-1}.

The logarithm ln⁡(BD)\ln(BD) is also dimensionless since its argument is dimensionless. Thus, the right-hand side Cln⁡(BD)C \ln(BD) has dimensions [C][C]. The left-hand side ADAD must have the same dimensions, so [A][D]=[C][A][D] = [C].

Now, we need to determine which of the given options is not a meaningful quantity. A meaningful quantity requires all terms in an expression to have the same dimensions, allowing operations like addition and subtraction.

Option A: CBD−A2D2C\frac{C}{BD} - \frac{A^2 D^2}{C}

Since BDBD is dimensionless, CBD\frac{C}{BD} has dimensions [C][C]. For A2D2C\frac{A^2 D^2}{C}, substitute [C]=[A][D][C] = [A][D]: dimensions are [A]2[D]2[A][D]=[A][D]=[C]\frac{[A]^2 [D]^2}{[A][D]} = [A][D] = [C]. Both terms have dimensions [C][C], so the expression is meaningful.

Option B: A2−B2C2A^2 - B^2 C^2

A2A^2 has dimensions [A]2[A]^2. For B2C2B^2 C^2, substitute [B]=[D]−1[B] = [D]^{-1} and [C]=[A][D][C] = [A][D]: dimensions are [D]−2⋅([A][D])2=[D]−2⋅[A]2[D]2=[A]2[D]^{-2} \cdot ([A][D])^2 = [D]^{-2} \cdot [A]^2 [D]^2 = [A]^2. Both terms have dimensions [A]2[A]^2, so the expression is meaningful.

Option C: AB−C\frac{A}{B} - C

AB\frac{A}{B} has dimensions [A][B]\frac{[A]}{[B]}. Substitute [B]=[D]−1[B] = [D]^{-1} and [C]=[A][D][C] = [A][D]: [A][D]−1=[A][D]=[C]\frac{[A]}{[D]^{-1}} = [A][D] = [C]. Both terms have dimensions [C][C], so the expression is meaningful.

Option D: A2−ACD\frac{A^2 - AC}{D}

First, examine the numerator A2−ACA^2 - AC. A2A^2 has dimensions [A]2[A]^2. ACAC has dimensions [A][C]=[A]⋅[A][D]=[A]2[D][A][C] = [A] \cdot [A][D] = [A]^2 [D] (since [C]=[A][D][C] = [A][D]). Since [D][D] is not dimensionless (as DD is not dimensionless and all quantities have different dimensions), [A]2≠[A]2[D][A]^2 \neq [A]^2 [D]. The terms A2A^2 and ACAC have different dimensions, so their subtraction is not allowed dimensionally. Thus, the expression is not meaningful.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Dimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicDimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations
TypeMultiple choice