JEE MAIN 2016 · 10 APR ONLINE+4 / −1HARDTRANSCRIBED
JEE Main 2016 Physics question — Errors in measurement and significant figures
A thin 1 m long rod has a radius of 5 mm. A force of 50π×103 N is applied at one end to determine its Young's modulus. Assume that the force is exactly known. If the least count in the measurement of all lengths is 0.01 mm, which of the following statements is false?
SOLUTION
The problem involves finding which statement is false regarding the determination of Young's modulus for a rod. The rod has a length L=1m and radius r=5mm=5×10−3m. A force F=50π×103N=50000πN is applied, and the least count for all length measurements is 0.01mm=10−5m. The force is exactly known, so its uncertainty is zero.
Young's modulus Y is given by:
Y=strainstress=ΔL/LF/A=A⋅ΔLF⋅L$
where A is the cross-sectional area and ΔL is the change in length. For a circular rod, A=πr2.
First, compute the area:
A=πr2=π(5×10−3)2=π×25×10−6=25π×10−6m2$
Substitute the values into the formula for Y:
Y=A⋅ΔLF⋅L=(25π×10−6)⋅ΔL(50000π)×1=25π×10−6⋅ΔL50000π=25×10−6⋅ΔL50000$
Simplify:
25×10−6⋅ΔL50000=25⋅ΔL50000×106=25⋅ΔL5×104×106=25⋅ΔL5×1010=ΔL2×109N/m2$
So, Y=ΔL2×109.
The maximum value of Y occurs when ΔL is minimum. The smallest measurable ΔL is the least count, 10−5m. Thus:
Ymax=10−52×109=2×1014N/m2$
Option A states that the maximum Y is 2×1014N m−2, which matches. So, A is true.
To analyze the relative uncertainty in Y, denoted YΔY, use error propagation. Since Y=AΔLFL and A=πr2, the relative uncertainty is:
YΔY=(FΔF)2+(LΔL)2+(2rΔr)2+(ΔLΔ(ΔL))2$
Given ΔF=0, this simplifies to:
YΔY=(LΔL)2+(2rΔr)2+(ΔLΔ(ΔL))2$
The uncertainties are:
- ΔL=10−5m (uncertainty in length L)
- Δr=10−5m (uncertainty in radius r)
- Δ(ΔL)=10−5m (uncertainty in change in length ΔL)
Substitute the values:
- L=1m, so LΔL=110−5=10−5
- r=5×10−3m, so rΔr=5×10−310−5=0.00510−5=2×10−3, and 2rΔr=2×2×10−3=4×10−3
- For ΔL, the minimum measurable value is 10−5m (since ΔL could be as small as the least count), so ΔLΔ(ΔL)=10−510−5=1
The squared contributions are:
- (LΔL)2=(10−5)2=10−10
- (2rΔr)2=(4×10−3)2=16×10−6=1.6×10−5
- (ΔLΔ(ΔL))2=(1)2=1
Thus:
YΔY=10−10+1.6×10−5+1≈1=1$
The contributions are dominated by the Δ(ΔL) term (which is 1), as the other terms are negligible.
Option B states that YΔY gets minimum contribution from the uncertainty in length L. The contribution from L is 10−10, while from r it is 1.6×10−5 and from ΔL it is 1. Since 10−10 is the smallest, B is true.
Option C states that YΔY gets its maximum contribution from the uncertainty in strain. Strain is ϵ=LΔL, and its uncertainty contributes via the terms for ΔL and Δ(ΔL). The relative uncertainty in strain is:
ϵΔϵ=(ΔLΔ(ΔL))2+(LΔL)2=12+(10−5)2≈1=1$
In YΔY, the strain contribution is approximately 1, which is the largest (compared to 1.6×10−5 and 10−10). So, C is true.
Option D states that the figure of merit is the largest for the length of the rod (meaning L). The figure of merit refers to the relative error contribution per unit measurement. The relative error contributions (without squaring) are:
- For L: LΔL=10−5
- For r: 2rΔr=4×10−3
- For ΔL: ΔLΔ(ΔL)=1
The contribution for ΔL (1) is the largest, followed by r (4×10−3), and then L (10−5). Thus, the figure of merit is largest for ΔL, not for L. Therefore, D is false.
Hence, the correct answer is Option D.
Tagged Errors in measurement and significant figures. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.