RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2015 · 10 APR ONLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2015 Physics question — Dimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations

If the capacitance of a nanocapacitor is measured in terms of a unit uu, made by combining the electronic charge ee, Bohr radius a0a_0, Planck's constant hh and speed of light cc then

SOLUTION

The capacitance uu is to be expressed in terms of the electronic charge ee, Bohr radius a0a_0, Planck's constant hh, and the speed of light cc. We use dimensional analysis to find the correct expression.

First, recall the dimensions of each quantity in terms of mass (M), length (L), time (T), and current (I):

  • Electronic charge ee has dimension [IT][I T].
  • Bohr radius a0a_0 has dimension [L][L].
  • Planck's constant hh has dimension [ML2T−1][M L^2 T^{-1}].
  • Speed of light cc has dimension [LT−1][L T^{-1}].

The capacitance uu has the dimension [M−1L−2T4I2][M^{-1} L^{-2} T^4 I^2]. We assume uu is proportional to ea×a0b×hc×cde^a \times a_0^b \times h^c \times c^d, so the dimensional equation is:

[M−1L−2T4I2]=[IT]a×[L]b×[ML2T−1]c×[LT−1]d[M^{-1} L^{-2} T^4 I^2] = [I T]^a \times [L]^b \times [M L^2 T^{-1}]^c \times [L T^{-1}]^d

Expanding the right side:

[IT]a=IaTa[I T]^a = I^a T^a

[L]b=Lb[L]^b = L^b

[ML2T−1]c=McL2cT−c[M L^2 T^{-1}]^c = M^c L^{2c} T^{-c}

[LT−1]d=LdT−d[L T^{-1}]^d = L^d T^{-d}

Combining these, the right side becomes:

Mc×Lb+2c+d×Ta−c−d×IaM^c \times L^{b + 2c + d} \times T^{a - c - d} \times I^a

Equating dimensions with the left side:

For mass (M): c=−1c = -1

For current (I): a=2a = 2

For time (T): a−c−d=4a - c - d = 4

Substituting a=2a = 2 and c=−1c = -1:

2−(−1)−d=42 - (-1) - d = 4

2+1−d=42 + 1 - d = 4

3−d=43 - d = 4

−d=1-d = 1

d=−1d = -1

For length (L): b+2c+d=−2b + 2c + d = -2

Substituting c=−1c = -1 and d=−1d = -1:

b+2(−1)+(−1)=−2b + 2(-1) + (-1) = -2

b−2−1=−2b - 2 - 1 = -2

b−3=−2b - 3 = -2

b=1b = 1

Thus, the exponents are a=2a = 2, b=1b = 1, c=−1c = -1, d=−1d = -1. The expression for capacitance is:

u∝e2×a01×h−1×c−1=e2a0hcu \propto e^2 \times a_0^1 \times h^{-1} \times c^{-1} = \frac{e^2 a_0}{h c}

Comparing with the options:

  • Option A: u=e2a0hcu = \frac{e^2 a_0}{h c} matches.
  • Option B: u=hce2a0u = \frac{h c}{e^2 a_0} is the reciprocal.
  • Option C: u=e2cha0u = \frac{e^2 c}{h a_0} does not match.
  • Option D: u=e2hca0u = \frac{e^2 h}{c a_0} does not match.

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Dimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicDimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations
TypeMultiple choice