RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2021 · 01 SEP S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2021 Physics question — Errors in measurement and significant figures

A student determined Young's Modulus of elasticity using the formula Y=Mgl34bd3δY = \frac{Mgl^3}{4bd^3\delta}. The value of gg is taken to be 9.8 m s−2^{-2} without any significant error, his observations are as following.

Figure for JEE Main 2021 Physics question on Errors in measurement and significant figures

Then the fractional error in the measurement of YY is:

SOLUTION

We have to find the fractional (relative) error in Young’s modulus, whose working formula for the experiment is Y=Mg l34 b d3 δ .Y=\frac{M g \, l^{3}}{4\, b\, d^{3}\, \delta}\, .

In error analysis, when a quantity is a product or quotient of measured quantities raised to powers, the fractional error in the result equals the algebraic sum of the absolute values of the fractional errors of each factor, each multiplied by its power. Stated formally, if Q=Ap Bq Cr…,Q = A^{p}\, B^{q}\, C^{r}\dots , then ΔQQ=∣p∣ΔAA+∣q∣ΔBB+∣r∣ΔCC+… .\frac{\Delta Q}{Q}=|p|\frac{\Delta A}{A}+|q|\frac{\Delta B}{B}+|r|\frac{\Delta C}{C}+\dots.

Comparing with Y=Mg l34 b d3 δ,Y=\dfrac{M g\, l^{3}}{4\, b\, d^{3}\, \delta}, we notice that gg and the numerical constant 44 are exact, so they contribute no error. The powers of the remaining variables are:

M+1,l+3,b−1,d−3,δ−1.M^{+1},\quad l^{+3},\quad b^{-1},\quad d^{-3},\quad \delta^{-1}.$

Therefore,

ΔYY=ΔMM+3Δll+Δbb+3Δdd+Δδδ.\frac{\Delta Y}{Y}= \frac{\Delta M}{M}+3\frac{\Delta l}{l}+\frac{\Delta b}{b}+3\frac{\Delta d}{d}+\frac{\Delta\delta}{\delta}.

The absolute error in each measurement is taken as its least count. We now convert every quantity and its least count to the same unit (SI) and evaluate each fractional error.

Mass: observed M=2 kg,least count=1 g=0.001 kg.M = 2\ \text{kg},\quad \text{least count}=1\ \text{g}=0.001\ \text{kg}.$
ΔMM=0.0012=0.0005.\frac{\Delta M}{M}= \frac{0.001}{2}=0.0005.

Length of bar: observed l=1 m,least count=1 mm=0.001 m.l = 1\ \text{m},\quad \text{least count}=1\ \text{mm}=0.001\ \text{m}.$
Δll=0.0011=0.001.\frac{\Delta l}{l}= \frac{0.001}{1}=0.001.

Breadth: observed b=4 cm=0.04 m,least count=0.1 mm=0.0001 m.b = 4\ \text{cm}=0.04\ \text{m},\quad \text{least count}=0.1\ \text{mm}=0.0001\ \text{m}.$
Δbb=0.00010.04=0.0025.\frac{\Delta b}{b}= \frac{0.0001}{0.04}=0.0025.

Thickness: observed d=0.4 cm=0.004 m,least count=0.01 mm=0.00001 m.d = 0.4\ \text{cm}=0.004\ \text{m},\quad \text{least count}=0.01\ \text{mm}=0.00001\ \text{m}.$
Δdd=0.000010.004=0.0025.\frac{\Delta d}{d}= \frac{0.00001}{0.004}=0.0025.

Depression: observed δ=5 mm=0.005 m,least count=0.01 mm=0.00001 m.\delta = 5\ \text{mm}=0.005\ \text{m},\quad \text{least count}=0.01\ \text{mm}=0.00001\ \text{m}.$
Δδδ=0.000010.005=0.002.\frac{\Delta \delta}{\delta}= \frac{0.00001}{0.005}=0.002.

Substituting all these fractional errors into the earlier relation, we get

ΔYY=0.0005  +  3(0.001)  +  0.0025  +  3(0.0025)  +  0.002=0.0005+0.003+0.0025+0.0075+0.002=0.0155.\begin{aligned} \frac{\Delta Y}{Y} &= 0.0005 \;+\; 3(0.001) \;+\; 0.0025 \;+\; 3(0.0025) \;+\; 0.002\\[4pt] &= 0.0005 + 0.003 + 0.0025 + 0.0075 + 0.002\\[4pt] &= 0.0155. \end{aligned}$

Thus the fractional error in the measurement of YY is 0.01550.0155.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Errors in measurement and significant figures. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicErrors in measurement and significant figures
TypeMultiple choice