RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 12 JAN S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Physics question — Heat conduction and thermal resistance

A cylinder of radius R is surrounded by a cylindrical shell of inner radius R and outer radius 2R. The thermal conductivity of the material of the inner cylinder is K1K_1 and that of the outer cylinder is K2K_2. Assuming no loss of heat, the effective thermal conductivity of the system for heat flowing along the length of the cylinder is:

SOLUTION

We have a solid cylinder of radius RR made of a material of thermal conductivity K1K_1. All around it, in perfect contact, there is a coaxial hollow cylindrical shell whose inner radius is also RR and whose outer radius is 2R2R. The shell is made of another material whose thermal conductivity is K2K_2. Heat is allowed to flow only along the axis (length) of the composite cylinder, and we assume that there is no loss of heat sideways. Our aim is to find one single number KeffK_{\text{eff}} that can replace the two conductors so that the heat flow calculated with KeffK_{\text{eff}} is exactly the same as the actual heat flow through the two materials taken together.

First, recall Fourier’s law of steady-state heat conduction along a length:

Q=K A ΔTL,Q = \dfrac{K\,A\,\Delta T}{L},

where

QQ = heat current (rate of heat flow),
KK = thermal conductivity of the material,
AA = cross-sectional area perpendicular to the heat flow,
ΔT\Delta T = temperature difference applied between the two ends, and
LL = length of the conductor in the direction of heat flow.

For axial (longitudinal) flow, each cylindrical region has its flat circular cross-section perpendicular to the flow. Because the two regions extend from the same hot face to the same cold face, the temperature difference ΔT\Delta T and the length LL are identical for both materials. Therefore both regions behave as parallel thermal conductors. In a parallel arrangement, individual heat currents simply add:

Qtotal=Q1+Q2.Q_{\text{total}} = Q_1 + Q_2.

Using Fourier’s law for each part we write

Q1=K1 A1 ΔTL,Q2=K2 A2 ΔTL.Q_1 = \dfrac{K_1\,A_1\,\Delta T}{L}, \qquad Q_2 = \dfrac{K_2\,A_2\,\Delta T}{L}.

Substituting these into the addition rule gives

Qtotal=K1 A1 ΔTL+K2 A2 ΔTL.Q_{\text{total}} = \dfrac{K_1\,A_1\,\Delta T}{L} + \dfrac{K_2\,A_2\,\Delta T}{L}.

Now we define the effective conductivity KeffK_{\text{eff}} through

Qtotal=Keff Atotal ΔTL,Q_{\text{total}} = \dfrac{K_{\text{eff}}\,A_{\text{total}}\,\Delta T}{L},

where AtotalA_{\text{total}} is the total cross-sectional area of the whole composite cylinder.

Equating the two expressions for QtotalQ_{\text{total}} and cancelling the common factors ΔT/L\Delta T/L on both sides, we obtain the relation

Keff Atotal=K1 A1+K2 A2.K_{\text{eff}}\,A_{\text{total}} = K_1\,A_1 + K_2\,A_2.

All that remains is to insert the actual areas. Because the cross-sections are circular, each area equals π×(radius)2\pi \times (\text{radius})^2.

Area of the inner solid cylinder:

A1=πR2.A_1 = \pi R^2.

Area of the outer hollow shell (annulus):

We subtract the inner area from the outer area: A2=π(2R)2  −  πR2=π(4R2−R2)=3πR2.A_2 = \pi (2R)^2 \;-\; \pi R^2 = \pi (4R^2 - R^2) = 3\pi R^2.

Total cross-sectional area of the composite cylinder:

Atotal=π(2R)2=4πR2.A_{\text{total}} = \pi (2R)^2 = 4\pi R^2.

Substituting A1,A2A_1, A_2 and AtotalA_{\text{total}} into the earlier relation gives

Keff (4πR2)=K1 (πR2)+K2 (3πR2).K_{\text{eff}}\,(4\pi R^2) = K_1\,(\pi R^2) + K_2\,(3\pi R^2).

We now cancel the common factor πR2\pi R^2 from every term:

4 Keff=K1+3K2.4\,K_{\text{eff}} = K_1 + 3K_2.

Solving for KeffK_{\text{eff}} we divide both sides by 44:

Keff=K1+3K24.K_{\text{eff}} = \dfrac{K_1 + 3K_2}{4}.

Therefore the effective thermal conductivity of the entire assembly is

Keff=K1+3K24.K_{\text{eff}} = \frac{K_1 + 3K_2}{4}.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Heat conduction and thermal resistance. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicHeat conduction and thermal resistance
TypeMultiple choice