RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2016 · 03 APR OFFLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2016 Physics question — Refraction at plane surfaces, Snell's law and apparent depth

In an experiment for determination of refractive index of glass of a prism by i v/s δ\delta plot, it was found that a ray incident at angle 35°, suffers a deviation of 40° and that it emerges at angle 79°. In that case which of the following is closest to the maximum possible value of the refractive index?

SOLUTION

First, we recall the two standard relations that hold for a prism of refracting angle AA and refractive index μ\mu:

1. The deviation produced for a given pair of angles of incidence ii and emergence ee is

δ=i+e−A.\delta=i+e-A.

2. When the deviation becomes minimum (that special value is denoted by δm\delta_m) the path of the ray inside the prism is symmetric, so i=e=imi=e=i_m and

μ=sin⁡ ⁣(A+δm2)sin⁡ ⁣(A2).\mu=\dfrac{\sin\!\left(\dfrac{A+\delta_m}{2}\right)}{\sin\!\left(\dfrac{A}{2}\right)}.

In the experiment one particular ray is reported to have

i=35∘,δ=40∘,e=79∘.i=35^\circ,\qquad \delta=40^\circ,\qquad e=79^\circ.

Using the first formula we find the prism angle AA:

δ=i+e−A40∘=35∘+79∘−AA=35∘+79∘−40∘A=74∘.\begin{aligned} \delta &= i+e-A\\[4pt] 40^\circ &= 35^\circ+79^\circ-A\\[4pt] A &= 35^\circ+79^\circ-40^\circ\\[4pt] A &= 74^\circ. \end{aligned}

The experiment has provided only one point on the ii versus δ\delta graph, so the actual minimum deviation δm\delta_m is not known exactly. However, the deviation curve is always U-shaped; hence the measured deviation of 40∘40^\circ can only be greater than or equal to the minimum deviation. Symbolically,

δm≤40∘.\delta_m\le 40^\circ.

The refractive index obtained from the second formula grows monotonically with δm\delta_m because the numerator sin⁡ ⁣(A+δm2)\sin\!\bigl(\tfrac{A+\delta_m}{2}\bigr) increases as δm\delta_m increases while the denominator is fixed. Therefore, the largest possible value of μ\mu will correspond to the largest admissible value of δm\delta_m, namely

δm(max)=40∘.\delta_m^{\text{(max)}}=40^\circ.

Substituting A=74∘A=74^\circ and δm=40∘\delta_m=40^\circ in the second relation gives

μmax=sin⁡ ⁣(A+δm2)sin⁡ ⁣(A2)=sin⁡ ⁣(74∘+40∘2)sin⁡ ⁣(74∘2)=sin⁡(57∘)sin⁡(37∘).\begin{aligned} \mu_{\text{max}}&=\dfrac{\sin\!\left(\dfrac{A+\delta_m}{2}\right)}{\sin\!\left(\dfrac{A}{2}\right)}\\[6pt] &=\dfrac{\sin\!\left(\dfrac{74^\circ+40^\circ}{2}\right)}{\sin\!\left(\dfrac{74^\circ}{2}\right)}\\[6pt] &=\dfrac{\sin(57^\circ)}{\sin(37^\circ)}.\\[6pt] \end{aligned}

Now we evaluate the sines step by step:

sin⁡(57∘)≈0.8387,sin⁡(37∘)≈0.6018,\sin(57^\circ)\approx0.8387,\qquad\sin(37^\circ)\approx0.6018,

so

μmax≈0.83870.6018≈1.39.\mu_{\text{max}}\approx\dfrac{0.8387}{0.6018}\approx1.39.

The numerical value 1.391.39 is not one of the quoted options. We must therefore look for the option that is closest to it. Comparing with the given choices

1.5,  1.6,  1.7,  1.8,1.5,\;1.6,\;1.7,\;1.8,

we see that 1.51.5 is the nearest to 1.391.39.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Refraction at plane surfaces, Snell's law and apparent depth. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicRefraction at plane surfaces, Snell's law and apparent depth
TypeMultiple choice