RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2017 · 02 APR OFFLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2017 Physics question — Stress, strain, Hooke's law and Young's modulus

A man grows into a giant such that his linear dimensions increase by a factor of 9. Assuming that his density remains same, the stress in the leg will change by a factor of:

SOLUTION

We have to compare the mechanical stress on the leg before and after the man becomes a giant. In mechanics, stress is defined first:

σ=FA\sigma=\frac{F}{A}

where σ\sigma is the stress, FF is the force acting on the area (here the weight of the body that the legs must support), and AA is the area over which that force is distributed (the cross-sectional area of the legs).

The problem states that all linear dimensions (height, width, depth, diameter of the leg, etc.) are enlarged by a common factor of 99. Let us call this scaling factor kk, so here k=9k = 9.

Step 1: How does the volume change?

The volume of any three-dimensional object is proportional to the cube of a characteristic length. Because every linear dimension grows by kk, the new volume V′V' becomes

V′=k3V=93V=729 V.V' = k^3 V = 9^3 V = 729\,V.

Step 2: How does the mass (and hence weight) change?

The density is given to remain the same. Mass is density times volume, so if volume increases by the factor 729729, mass increases by exactly the same factor:

m′=729 m.m' = 729\,m.

The weight is the gravitational force F=mgF = mg. Therefore, the new weight F′F' is

F′=m′g=729 mg=729 F.F' = m' g = 729\,m g = 729\,F.

Step 3: How does the supporting area of the leg change?

The cross-section of the leg is a two-dimensional quantity, so it scales with the square of the linear factor:

A′=k2A=92A=81 A.A' = k^2 A = 9^2 A = 81\,A.

Step 4: Compute the new stress.

Using the stress formula on the enlarged man, we have

σ′=F′A′=729 F81 A.\sigma' = \frac{F'}{A'} = \frac{729\,F}{81\,A}.

We now separate the numerical factor:

σ′=72981 FA=9 σ.\sigma' = \frac{729}{81}\,\frac{F}{A} = 9\,\sigma.

So the stress in the giant’s legs is nine times the original stress.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Stress, strain, Hooke's law and Young's modulus. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicStress, strain, Hooke's law and Young's modulus
TypeMultiple choice