RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 05 SEP S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Physics question — Archimedes' principle and floatation

A hollow spherical shell at outer radius RR floats just submerged under the water surface. The inner radius of the shell is rr. If the specific gravity of the shell material is 278\frac{27}{8} with respect to water, the value of rr is:

SOLUTION

We have a thin‐walled hollow sphere whose outer radius is RR and inner radius is rr. Its material has specific gravity 278\dfrac{27}{8} with respect to water. Specific gravity is defined as

specific gravity=density of substancedensity of water.\text{specific gravity}=\dfrac{\text{density of substance}}{\text{density of water}}.

So, if we denote the density of water by ρ\rho, the density of the shell material is

ρ ⁣s=278 ρ.\rho_{\!s}=\dfrac{27}{8}\,\rho.

Because the sphere floats just submerged, the whole external volume (43πR3)\left(\dfrac{4}{3}\pi R^{3}\right) is under water. According to Archimedes’ principle, the buoyant force equals the weight of the water displaced, i.e.

Fbuoyant=ρ g(43πR3).F_{\text{buoyant}}=\rho\,g\left(\dfrac{4}{3}\pi R^{3}\right).

The weight of the body that must be supported is simply the weight of the shell material (the air inside has negligible mass). Its volume is the difference between the outer and inner volumes, so

Fweight=ρ ⁣s g[43π(R3−r3)]=278ρ g[43π(R3−r3)].F_{\text{weight}}=\rho_{\!s}\,g\left[\dfrac{4}{3}\pi\left(R^{3}-r^{3}\right)\right]=\dfrac{27}{8}\rho\,g\left[\dfrac{4}{3}\pi\left(R^{3}-r^{3}\right)\right].

For floating equilibrium we set buoyant force equal to weight:

ρ g(43πR3)=278ρ g[43π(R3−r3)].\rho\,g\left(\dfrac{4}{3}\pi R^{3}\right)=\dfrac{27}{8}\rho\,g\left[\dfrac{4}{3}\pi\left(R^{3}-r^{3}\right)\right].

Now we cancel the common factors ρ, g,\rho,\,g, and 43π\dfrac{4}{3}\pi from both sides:

R3=278(R3−r3).R^{3}=\dfrac{27}{8}\left(R^{3}-r^{3}\right).

Multiplying through by 88 gives

8R3=27(R3−r3).8R^{3}=27\left(R^{3}-r^{3}\right).

Expanding the right-hand side,

8R3=27R3−27r3.8R^{3}=27R^{3}-27r^{3}.

Rearranging to isolate r3,r^{3},

27r3=27R3−8R3=19R3,27r^{3}=27R^{3}-8R^{3}=19R^{3},

hence

r3=1927R3.r^{3}=\dfrac{19}{27}R^{3}.

Taking the cube root of both sides we obtain

rR=(1927)1/3≈0.889.\dfrac{r}{R}=\left(\dfrac{19}{27}\right)^{1/3}\approx0.889.

The numerical value 0.8890.889 is practically equal to 89=0.888…\dfrac{8}{9}=0.888\dots Therefore,

r  ≈  89R.r\;\approx\;\dfrac{8}{9}R.

Among the alternatives, this matches Option A.

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Archimedes' principle and floatation. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicArchimedes' principle and floatation
TypeMultiple choice