The specific heats, C and C of a gas of diatomic molecules, A, are given (in units of J mol K) by 29 and 22, respectively. Another gas of diatomic molecules, B, has the corresponding values 30 and 21. If they are treated as ideal gases, then:
For an ideal gas the molar heat capacities at constant pressure and volume are related by the very first identity we always quote
where is the universal gas constant. In addition, the total molar internal energy is written in the form
with denoting the total number of quadratic degrees of freedom that are actually “active” at the temperature of the experiment. Because
we obtain immediately the useful pair of working formulae
Finally we define the ratio of heat capacities
Now we recall the textbook values for a diatomic molecule:
Hence
With the theory organised, let us examine the two experimental gases.
Gas A. The given numbers are
We use the difference to obtain the effective that belongs to the same set of rounded data:
With this value the effective number of degrees of freedom is
This figure is distinctly larger than 5 and lies quite close to the ideal value 7 that one gets when a single vibrational mode is active. We confirm the same tendency by the ratio
which is very near the theoretical 1.29 for a diatomic possessing one vibrational mode, and markedly below 1.40 for a rigid diatomic. Hence Gas A does possess its vibrational mode.
Gas B. The quoted values are
First compute the rounded difference:
Now derive the corresponding :
This result is very close to 5 and far from 7, so the only degrees of freedom effectively operating are the three translational and the two rotational ones; the vibrational mode is evidently still “frozen out.” The heat-capacity ratio reinforces the same conclusion:
essentially the theoretical 1.40 expected for a rigid diatomic with no vibrational contribution.
Putting the two discussions together we find that Gas A has its single vibrational mode active, whereas Gas B behaves as a rigid diatomic molecule with no vibrational contribution.
Hence, the correct answer is Option B.
Tagged Molar specific heats of gases, Mayer's relation and gas mixtures. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.