For a gas in a state P and in a state Q. and are the temperatures in two different states P and Q, respectively. Then
The difference between the molar heat capacities of any fluid is given by the exact thermodynamic identity
For an ideal gas the equation of state is and after inserting this equation in the above identity one gets the familiar Mayer relation which is independent of temperature. A departure of the value of from therefore signals non-ideal behaviour, so we must work with a more realistic equation of state. The simplest and most frequently used one is the van der Waals equation
in which the parameters and account, respectively, for intermolecular attraction and the finite size of the molecules.
We now calculate the two derivatives that enter the heat-capacity identity.
First, keeping volume constant,
Secondly, keeping temperature constant,
Substituting these derivatives into the general expression, we obtain
The two negative signs in the numerator and denominator cancel, and a factor can be taken out of the denominator to give
Write this result in the more compact form
Observe the structure of the denominator in (1). The fraction
is strictly positive (all the symbols denote positive quantities) and it is divided by . Hence
In other words, the difference is inversely related to the temperature for a real gas described by the van der Waals equation: a greater value of corresponds to a lower temperature.
Let us now compare the two given states.
State : (the ideal value)
State : (10 % larger than the ideal value)
Because the above reasoning tells us that state must be at a lower temperature than state . Symbolically,
So, the correct inequality is
Hence, the correct answer is Option D.
Tagged Molar specific heats of gases, Mayer's relation and gas mixtures. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.