RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2021 · 25 JUL S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2021 Physics question — Molar specific heats of gases, Mayer's relation and gas mixtures

For a gas CP−CV=RC_P - C_V = R in a state P and CP−CV=1.10RC_P - C_V = 1.10R in a state Q. TPT_P and TQT_Q are the temperatures in two different states P and Q, respectively. Then

SOLUTION

The difference between the molar heat capacities of any fluid is given by the exact thermodynamic identity

CP−CV  =  − T  (∂P∂T)V2(∂P∂V)T.C_P-C_V \;=\; -\,T\; \frac{\left(\dfrac{\partial P}{\partial T}\right)_{V}^{2}} {\left(\dfrac{\partial P}{\partial V}\right)_{T}}.

For an ideal gas the equation of state is P V=R TP\,V = R\,T and after inserting this equation in the above identity one gets the familiar Mayer relation CP−CV=R,C_P-C_V=R, which is independent of temperature. A departure of the value of CP−CVC_P-C_V from RR therefore signals non-ideal behaviour, so we must work with a more realistic equation of state. The simplest and most frequently used one is the van der Waals equation

P=R TV−b−aV2,P=\frac{R\,T}{V-b}-\frac{a}{V^{2}},

in which the parameters aa and bb account, respectively, for intermolecular attraction and the finite size of the molecules.

We now calculate the two derivatives that enter the heat-capacity identity.

First, keeping volume constant,

(∂P∂T)V=RV−b.\left(\frac{\partial P}{\partial T}\right)_{V} =\frac{R}{V-b}.

Secondly, keeping temperature constant,

(∂P∂V)T=−R T(V−b)2+2aV3.\left(\frac{\partial P}{\partial V}\right)_{T} = -\frac{R\,T}{(V-b)^{2}}+\frac{2a}{V^{3}}.

Substituting these derivatives into the general expression, we obtain

CP−CV=− T  (RV−b)2−R T(V−b)2+2aV3.C_P-C_V = -\,T\; \frac{\displaystyle\left(\dfrac{R}{V-b}\right)^{2}} {\displaystyle -\frac{R\,T}{(V-b)^{2}}+\frac{2a}{V^{3}}}.

The two negative signs in the numerator and denominator cancel, and a factor R T(V−b)2\dfrac{R\,T}{(V-b)^{2}} can be taken out of the denominator to give

CP−CV=T R2/(V−b)2 R T/(V−b)2 [ 1−2a(V−b)2R T V3]=R1−2a(V−b)2R T V3.C_P-C_V = \frac{T\,R^{2}/(V-b)^{2}} {\,R\,T/(V-b)^{2}\, \Bigl[\,1-\dfrac{2a(V-b)^{2}}{R\,T\,V^{3}}\Bigr]} = \frac{R}{1-\dfrac{2a(V-b)^{2}}{R\,T\,V^{3}}}.

Write this result in the more compact form

CP−CV=  R  [ 1−2a (V−b)2R T V3]−1.−(1)C_P-C_V =\;R\; \Biggl[\, 1-\frac{2a\,(V-b)^{2}}{R\,T\,V^{3}} \Biggr]^{-1}. \quad -(1)

Observe the structure of the denominator in (1). The fraction

2a (V−b)2R T V3\frac{2a\,(V-b)^{2}}{R\,T\,V^{3}}

is strictly positive (all the symbols denote positive quantities) and it is divided by TT. Hence

  • When the temperature TT is very high, the term 2a (V−b)2R T V3\dfrac{2a\,(V-b)^{2}}{R\,T\,V^{3}} becomes small, the bracket approaches 11 and (1) reduces to CP−CV≈RC_P-C_V\approx R - the ideal-gas limit.
  • When the temperature TT is lowered, the same term becomes larger, the entire bracket becomes smaller than 1, and therefore its reciprocal, and with it CP−CV,C_P-C_V, becomes larger than RR.

In other words, the difference CP−CVC_P-C_V is inversely related to the temperature for a real gas described by the van der Waals equation: a greater value of CP−CVC_P-C_V corresponds to a lower temperature.

Let us now compare the two given states.

State PP: CP−CV=RC_P-C_V = R (the ideal value)
State QQ: CP−CV=1.10 RC_P-C_V = 1.10\,R (10 % larger than the ideal value)

Because 1.10 R  >  R,1.10\,R \;>\; R, the above reasoning tells us that state QQ must be at a lower temperature than state PP. Symbolically,

TQ  <TP.T_Q \;< T_P.

So, the correct inequality is

TP  >  TQ.T_P \;>\; T_Q.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Molar specific heats of gases, Mayer's relation and gas mixtures. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicMolar specific heats of gases, Mayer's relation and gas mixtures
TypeMultiple choice