RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 12 JAN S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Physics question — Ideal gas equation and gas laws

A vertical closed cylinder is separated into two parts by a frictionless piston of mass m and of negligible thickness. The piston is free to move along the length of the cylinder. The length of the cylinder above piston is l1l_1, and that below the piston is l2l_2, such that l1>l2l_1 > l_2. Each part of the cylinder contains n moles of an ideal gas at equal temperature T. If the piston is stationary, its mass m will be given by: (R is universal gas constant and g is the acceleration due to gravity)

SOLUTION

We have a vertical cylinder of uniform cross-sectional area AA. A light, frictionless piston of mass mm separates the cylinder into an upper part of length l1l_1 and a lower part of length l2l_2, with l1>l2l_1 > l_2. Each part contains nn moles of an ideal gas at the same absolute temperature TT. Because the piston is at rest, the forces acting on it must balance perfectly.

For each gas sample we write the ideal-gas equation. The ideal-gas law states

PV=nRT,PV = nRT,

where PP is pressure, VV is volume, nn is the number of moles, RR is the universal gas constant and TT is the absolute temperature.

First for the gas above the piston, whose pressure is P1P_1 and volume is V1=A l1V_1 = A\,l_1, we obtain

P1V1=nRT    ⟹    P1(A l1)=nRT    ⟹    P1=nRTA l1.P_1 V_1 = nRT \;\;\Longrightarrow\;\; P_1 (A\,l_1) = nRT \;\;\Longrightarrow\;\; P_1 = \frac{nRT}{A\,l_1}.

Next for the gas below the piston, whose pressure is P2P_2 and volume is V2=A l2V_2 = A\,l_2, we write

P2V2=nRT    ⟹    P2(A l2)=nRT    ⟹    P2=nRTA l2.P_2 V_2 = nRT \;\;\Longrightarrow\;\; P_2 (A\,l_2) = nRT \;\;\Longrightarrow\;\; P_2 = \frac{nRT}{A\,l_2}.

Now we look at the forces acting on the piston. The upward force on the piston is the pressure exerted by the lower gas times area AA, namely P2AP_2A. The downward forces are the pressure exerted by the upper gas, P1AP_1A, and the weight of the piston, mgmg. For mechanical equilibrium (piston stationary) we therefore set

Upward force=Downward force\text{Upward force} = \text{Downward force}

P2A=P1A+mg.P_2A = P_1A + mg.

Solving for the weight term, we write

mg=A (P2−P1).mg = A\,(P_2 - P_1).

We now substitute the expressions for P1P_1 and P2P_2 obtained from the ideal-gas law:

mg=A ⁣(nRTA l2−nRTA l1).mg = A\!\left(\frac{nRT}{A\,l_2} - \frac{nRT}{A\,l_1}\right).

The area AA cancels out:

mg=nRT ⁣(1l2−1l1).mg = nRT\!\left(\frac{1}{l_2} - \frac{1}{l_1}\right).

We combine the fractions inside the parentheses:

1l2−1l1=l1−l2l1 l2.\frac{1}{l_2} - \frac{1}{l_1} = \frac{l_1 - l_2}{l_1\,l_2}.

Substituting this result gives

mg=nRT ⁣(l1−l2l1 l2).mg = nRT\!\left(\frac{l_1 - l_2}{l_1\,l_2}\right).

Finally we isolate the mass mm by dividing both sides by gg:

m=nRTg ⁣(l1−l2l1 l2).m = \frac{nRT}{g}\!\left(\frac{l_1 - l_2}{l_1\,l_2}\right).

This expression matches option B.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Ideal gas equation and gas laws. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicIdeal gas equation and gas laws
TypeMultiple choice