RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 09 JAN S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Physics question — Satellites: orbital speed, period, energy and geostationary orbits

A body A of mass mm is moving in a circular orbit of radius RR about a planet. Another body B of mass m2\frac{m}{2} collides with A with a velocity which is half (v2)\left(\frac{v}{2}\right) the instantaneous velocity v⃗\vec{v} of A. The collision is completely inelastic. Then, the combined body:

SOLUTION

Let the mass of the planet be MM. At the instant just before the collision body AA of mass mm is moving in a circular path of radius RR with speed vv. For a circular orbit we first recall the condition obtained by equating the required centripetal force to the gravitational attraction

mv2R=GMmR2  ,⇒v2=GMR\frac{m v^{2}}{R}= \frac{G M m}{R^{2}}\; ,\qquad\Rightarrow\qquad v^{2}= \frac{G M}{R}

The gravitational potential energy of AA in that orbit is

UA=− GMmR=−mv2U_{A}= -\,\frac{G M m}{R}= -m v^{2}

and its kinetic energy is

KA=12mv2K_{A}= \frac12 m v^{2}

so the total mechanical energy of AA is

EA=KA+UA=12mv2−mv2=−12mv2E_{A}=K_{A}+U_{A}=\frac12 m v^{2}-m v^{2}= -\frac12 m v^{2}

Now a second body BB of mass m2\dfrac{m}{2} approaches and collides head-on (along the same tangential direction) with AA with speed v2\dfrac{v}{2}. The collision is completely inelastic, hence the two bodies stick together. During the very short collision the only significant forces are their mutual internal forces; the external gravitational force acts radially and therefore exerts no impulse in the tangential direction. Consequently the linear (tangential) momentum is conserved.

Initial tangential momentum:

pinitial  =  m v  +  m2 v2  =  mv+14mv  =  54 mvp_{\text{initial}} \;=\; m\,v \;+\;\frac{m}{2}\,\frac{v}{2}\;=\;m v+\frac14 m v \;=\;\frac54\,m v

Total mass after collision:

mtot=m+m2=32 mm_{\text{tot}} = m+\frac{m}{2}= \frac32\,m

If VV is the common speed immediately after sticking together, conservation of momentum gives

54 mv=32 m V⇒V=5432 v=54×23 v=56 v\frac54\,m v = \frac32\,m\,V \quad\Rightarrow\quad V = \frac{\frac54}{\frac32}\,v = \frac{5}{4}\times\frac{2}{3}\,v = \frac56\,v

Thus the speed of the combined body has fallen to 56 v\dfrac56\,v.

Its kinetic energy right after the collision is

K′=12(32 m)V2=34 m (56 v)2=34 m 2536 v2=2548 mv2K' = \frac12\Bigl(\frac32\,m\Bigr) V^{2} =\frac34\,m\,\Bigl(\frac56\,v\Bigr)^{2} =\frac34\,m\,\frac{25}{36}\,v^{2} =\frac{25}{48}\,m v^{2}

The collision occurs at the same distance RR from the planet, so the gravitational potential energy of the combined body is

U′=− GMR(32 m)=−32 m v2U' = -\,\frac{G M}{R}\Bigl(\frac32\,m\Bigr) =-\frac32\,m\,v^{2} (because v2=GMRv^{2}= \dfrac{G M}{R})

Hence the total mechanical energy after collision is

E′=K′+U′=2548 mv2  −  32 mv2=2548 mv2−7248 mv2=−4748 mv2E' = K' + U' = \frac{25}{48}\,m v^{2} \;-\;\frac32\,m v^{2} = \frac{25}{48}\,m v^{2}-\frac{72}{48}\,m v^{2} = -\frac{47}{48}\,m v^{2}

We immediately notice that E′E' is negative, so the system is still gravitationally bound; therefore it cannot escape (escape requires E≥0E\ge 0).

Next, compare the new speed V=56 vV=\dfrac56\,v with the speed required for a circular orbit at radius RR. The circular-orbit speed does not depend on the mass of the moving body, and we have already found it to be vv. Because

V=56 v  <  vV=\frac56\,v \;\lt \; v

the combined body has less speed than needed for a circular path, so it cannot continue in the same circular orbit. However, its angular momentum about the planet is not zero:

L′=mtotVR=(32 m)(56 v)R=54 mvR≠0L' = m_{\text{tot}} V R = \Bigl(\frac32\,m\Bigr)\Bigl(\frac56\,v\Bigr)R = \frac54\,m v R \ne 0

Because angular momentum is non-zero the body cannot fall straight towards the planet; instead it must follow another bound orbit. For a gravitational potential, bound non-circular orbits are elliptical. Hence the new path is an ellipse with the point of collision lying on that ellipse (specifically at the apogee, since the speed there is lower than the circular value).

Therefore the combined body starts moving in an elliptical orbit around the planet.

Hence, the correct answer is Option 4.

Tagged Satellites: orbital speed, period, energy and geostationary orbits. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicSatellites: orbital speed, period, energy and geostationary orbits
TypeMultiple choice