RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2016 · 03 APR OFFLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2016 Physics question — Electric flux and Gauss's law

The region between two concentric spheres of radii 'a' and 'b', respectively (see figure), has volume charge density ρ=Ar\rho = \frac{A}{r}, where A is a constant and r is the distance from the centre. At the centre of the spheres is a point charge Q. The value of A such that the electric field in the region between the spheres will be constant, is:

Figure for JEE Main 2016 Physics question on Electric flux and Gauss's law
SOLUTION

First, let us identify the geometry. We have two concentric spheres with radii aa and bb satisfying a<r<ba < r < b. The shell lying between these two radii is filled with a volume charge whose density varies as ρ=Ar\rho = \dfrac{A}{r}, while the very centre (at r=0r = 0) carries a point charge QQ.

We wish to make the electric field E(r)E(r) anywhere in the region a<r<ba < r < b the same for all values of rr, that is, independent of rr. To obtain the required value of AA we use Gauss’s law.

Gauss’s law in integral form states

∮SE⃗⋅dS⃗  =  1ε0 Qenc.\displaystyle \oint_S \vec E \cdot d\vec S \;=\;\frac{1}{\varepsilon_0}\,Q_{\text{enc}}.

For spherical symmetry, we choose a Gaussian surface that is itself a sphere of radius rr (with a<r<ba < r < b). On this surface the magnitude E(r)E(r) is the same everywhere and the flux becomes

E(r) (4πr2)  =  1ε0 Qenc(r).E(r)\,(4\pi r^2)\;=\;\frac{1}{\varepsilon_0}\,Q_{\text{enc}}(r).

So

E(r)=Qenc(r)4πε0 r2.E(r)=\frac{Q_{\text{enc}}(r)}{4\pi\varepsilon_0\,r^2}.

Now we calculate the total charge enclosed inside radius rr, namely

Qenc(r)=Qpoint+Qshell up to r.Q_{\text{enc}}(r)=Q_{\text{point}}+Q_{\text{shell up to }r}.

The point charge contributes simply Qpoint=Q.Q_{\text{point}} = Q.

For the shell portion (from aa out to rr) we integrate the given volume charge density. The differential charge in a thin spherical shell of radius r′r' and thickness dr′dr' is

dQ=ρ(r′) dτ=Ar′  (4πr′2 dr′)=4πA r′ dr′.dQ = \rho(r')\,d\tau = \frac{A}{r'}\;\bigl(4\pi r'^2\,dr'\bigr)=4\pi A\,r'\,dr'.

Integrating from r′=ar' = a to r′=rr' = r gives

Qshell up to r=4πA∫arr′ dr′Q_{\text{shell up to }r}=4\pi A\int_{a}^{r}r'\,dr'

=4πA[r′22]ar\hspace{3.55cm}=4\pi A\left[\frac{r'^2}{2}\right]_{a}^{r}

=2πA(r2−a2).\hspace{3.55cm}=2\pi A\bigl(r^2 - a^2\bigr).

Hence

Qenc(r)=Q+2πA(r2−a2).Q_{\text{enc}}(r)=Q+2\pi A\bigl(r^2-a^2\bigr).

Substituting this into the earlier result for E(r)E(r) we obtain

E(r)=Q+2πA(r2−a2)4πε0 r2.E(r)=\frac{Q+2\pi A\bigl(r^2-a^2\bigr)}{4\pi\varepsilon_0\,r^2}.

We now enforce the requirement that E(r)E(r) must not depend on rr. For that to happen, the numerator must be directly proportional to r2r^2 so that the r2r^2 in the denominator cancels out and leaves a constant.

Let us write the numerator in the desired proportional form:

Q+2πA(r2−a2)=k r2,Q+2\pi A\bigl(r^2-a^2\bigr)=k\,r^2,

where kk is some constant (its exact value is immaterial—only the absence of any other rr-dependence matters).

Comparing coefficients of like powers of rr on both sides, we see:

 • For the r2r^2 terms: 2πA=k.2\pi A=k.
 • For the terms independent of rr: Q−2πAa2=0.Q-2\pi A a^2=0.

The second equality immediately gives us the needed value of AA:

Q−2πAa2=0    ⟹    A=Q2πa2.Q-2\pi A a^2=0\;\;\Longrightarrow\;\;A=\frac{Q}{2\pi a^2}.

This is a unique choice; any other value would leave residual rr-dependence in the field.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Electric flux and Gauss's law. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicElectric flux and Gauss's law
TypeMultiple choice