For which of the following particles will it be most difficult to experimentally verify the de-Broglie relationship?
The de-Broglie relationship states that the wavelength associated with a moving particle is given by , where is Planck's constant and is the momentum of the particle. The momentum is equal to , where is the mass and is the velocity. Therefore, .
To experimentally verify the de-Broglie relationship, we need to observe wave-like behavior such as diffraction or interference. This requires the de-Broglie wavelength to be comparable to the size of the slits or obstacles in the experiment, typically on the order of atomic dimensions (about m). If the wavelength is too small, the wave effects become negligible and difficult to detect.
The wavelength is inversely proportional to the mass for a given velocity . Therefore, heavier particles will have shorter wavelengths, making it harder to observe their wave nature.
Now, comparing the masses of the given particles:
Since the dust particle has the largest mass, its de-Broglie wavelength will be the smallest for the same velocity. For example, assuming the same velocity :
Given kg and kg (approximately), the ratio is:
Thus, is about times smaller than . Even if the dust particle is moving very fast, its wavelength remains extremely small. For instance, with typical velocities, might be around m or smaller, far below atomic scales ( m), making it impossible to detect with current technology.
In contrast, electrons, protons, and -particles have been used in experiments like electron diffraction or Rutherford scattering to confirm wave-particle duality because their wavelengths are measurable.
Hence, the dust particle poses the greatest experimental challenge for verifying the de-Broglie relationship.
So, the answer is Option C.
Tagged de Broglie wavelength of matter waves. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.