RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2014 · 09 APR ONLINE+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2014 Physics question — de Broglie wavelength of matter waves

For which of the following particles will it be most difficult to experimentally verify the de-Broglie relationship?

SOLUTION

The de-Broglie relationship states that the wavelength λ\lambda associated with a moving particle is given by λ=hp\lambda = \frac{h}{p}, where hh is Planck's constant and pp is the momentum of the particle. The momentum pp is equal to m×vm \times v, where mm is the mass and vv is the velocity. Therefore, λ=hmv\lambda = \frac{h}{m v}.

To experimentally verify the de-Broglie relationship, we need to observe wave-like behavior such as diffraction or interference. This requires the de-Broglie wavelength to be comparable to the size of the slits or obstacles in the experiment, typically on the order of atomic dimensions (about 10−1010^{-10} m). If the wavelength is too small, the wave effects become negligible and difficult to detect.

The wavelength λ\lambda is inversely proportional to the mass mm for a given velocity vv. Therefore, heavier particles will have shorter wavelengths, making it harder to observe their wave nature.

Now, comparing the masses of the given particles:

  • An electron has a mass of approximately 9.1×10−319.1 \times 10^{-31} kg.
  • A proton has a mass of approximately 1.67×10−271.67 \times 10^{-27} kg, which is about 1836 times the mass of an electron.
  • An α\alpha-particle (helium nucleus) has a mass of approximately 6.64×10−276.64 \times 10^{-27} kg, which is about 4 times the mass of a proton.
  • A dust particle is macroscopic. Even a very small dust particle, say with a diameter of 1 micrometer and density of 20002000 kg/m³, has a mass of about 10−1510^{-15} kg. This is many orders of magnitude larger than subatomic particles.

Since the dust particle has the largest mass, its de-Broglie wavelength will be the smallest for the same velocity. For example, assuming the same velocity vv:

λelectron=hmev\lambda_{\text{electron}} = \frac{h}{m_{\text{e}} v}

λdust=hmdustv\lambda_{\text{dust}} = \frac{h}{m_{\text{dust}} v}

Given mdust≈10−15m_{\text{dust}} \approx 10^{-15} kg and me≈10−30m_{\text{e}} \approx 10^{-30} kg (approximately), the ratio is:

λdustλelectron=memdust≈10−3010−15=10−15\frac{\lambda_{\text{dust}}}{\lambda_{\text{electron}}} = \frac{m_{\text{e}}}{m_{\text{dust}}} \approx \frac{10^{-30}}{10^{-15}} = 10^{-15}

Thus, λdust\lambda_{\text{dust}} is about 101510^{15} times smaller than λelectron\lambda_{\text{electron}}. Even if the dust particle is moving very fast, its wavelength remains extremely small. For instance, with typical velocities, λdust\lambda_{\text{dust}} might be around 10−2510^{-25} m or smaller, far below atomic scales (10−1010^{-10} m), making it impossible to detect with current technology.

In contrast, electrons, protons, and α\alpha-particles have been used in experiments like electron diffraction or Rutherford scattering to confirm wave-particle duality because their wavelengths are measurable.

Hence, the dust particle poses the greatest experimental challenge for verifying the de-Broglie relationship.

So, the answer is Option C.

Tagged de Broglie wavelength of matter waves. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
Topicde Broglie wavelength of matter waves
TypeMultiple choice