RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2021 · 25 JUL S1+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2021 Physics question — de Broglie wavelength of matter waves

A particle of mass 4M at rest disintegrates into two particles of mass M and 3M, respectively, having non zero velocities. The ratio of de-Broglie wavelength of particle of mass M to that of mass 3M will be:

SOLUTION

We have a single particle whose initial mass is 4M4M and it is stated to be at rest. “At rest’’ means that its initial linear momentum is zero, i.e. p⃗initial=0\vec p_{\text{initial}} = 0.

This particle suddenly disintegrates into two separate particles. The first fragment has mass MM and the second fragment has mass 3M3M. Let their velocities after disintegration be v⃗1\vec v_1 (for the particle of mass MM) and v⃗2\vec v_2 (for the particle of mass 3M3M). Because the original body was isolated and at rest, the law of conservation of linear momentum must hold.

Conservation of momentum (statement). For an isolated system, the vector sum of the momenta before and after any internal interaction remains unchanged.

Applying this law, we write

M v⃗1  +  3M v⃗2  =  0⃗.M\,\vec v_1 \;+\; 3M\,\vec v_2 \;=\; \vec 0.

We now proceed algebraically, isolating one velocity in terms of the other. Dividing every term by the common factor MM gives

v⃗1  +  3 v⃗2  =  0⃗.\vec v_1 \;+\; 3\,\vec v_2 \;=\; \vec 0.

Rearranging, we get

v⃗1  =  − 3 v⃗2.\vec v_1 \;=\; -\,3\,\vec v_2.

This result tells us that the two velocities are in opposite directions (the minus sign) and that the magnitude of v⃗1\vec v_1 is three times the magnitude of v⃗2\vec v_2:

∣v⃗1∣  =  3 ∣v⃗2∣.|\vec v_1| \;=\; 3\,|\vec v_2|.

Next, we write the individual momenta after the disintegration:

First particle (mass MM): p⃗1  =  M v⃗1.\vec p_1 \;=\; M\,\vec v_1.

Second particle (mass 3M3M): p⃗2  =  3M v⃗2.\vec p_2 \;=\; 3M\,\vec v_2.

We take magnitudes to compare them. Using ∣v⃗1∣=3 ∣v⃗2∣|\vec v_1| = 3\,|\vec v_2|, we have

∣p⃗1∣  =  M ∣v⃗1∣  =  M (3 ∣v⃗2∣)  =  3M ∣v⃗2∣.|\vec p_1| \;=\; M\,|\vec v_1| \;=\; M\,(3\,|\vec v_2|) \;=\; 3M\,|\vec v_2|.

Similarly,

∣p⃗2∣  =  3M ∣v⃗2∣.|\vec p_2| \;=\; 3M\,|\vec v_2|.

From the last two lines we observe

∣p⃗1∣=∣p⃗2∣.|\vec p_1| = |\vec p_2|.

Thus, although the particles have different masses and different speeds, the magnitudes of their linear momenta are identical, fulfilling momentum conservation.

Now we invoke the de-Broglie relation.

de-Broglie wavelength formula. The wavelength associated with a particle of momentum pp is

λ=hp,\lambda = \dfrac{h}{p},

where hh is Planck’s constant.

Let λ1\lambda_1 be the wavelength of the particle of mass MM and λ2\lambda_2 be that of the particle of mass 3M3M. Then

λ1=h∣p⃗1∣,λ2=h∣p⃗2∣.\lambda_1 = \dfrac{h}{|\vec p_1|}, \qquad \lambda_2 = \dfrac{h}{|\vec p_2|}.

We now form the required ratio:

λ1λ2=h/∣p⃗1∣ h/∣p⃗2∣ =∣p⃗2∣∣p⃗1∣.\dfrac{\lambda_1}{\lambda_2} = \dfrac{h/|\vec p_1|}{\,h/|\vec p_2|\,} = \dfrac{|\vec p_2|}{|\vec p_1|}.

But we have already shown that ∣p⃗1∣=∣p⃗2∣|\vec p_1| = |\vec p_2|, so

λ1λ2=1.\dfrac{\lambda_1}{\lambda_2} = 1.

This translates to the numerical ratio

λ1:λ2=1:1.\lambda_1 : \lambda_2 = 1 : 1.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged de Broglie wavelength of matter waves. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
Topicde Broglie wavelength of matter waves
TypeMultiple choice