RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2013 · 25 APR ONLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2013 Physics question — Photoelectric effect and Einstein's equation

In an experiment on photoelectric effect, a student plots stopping potential V0V_0 against reciprocal of the wavelength λ\lambda of the incident light for two different metals A and B. These are shown in the figure.

Figure for JEE Main 2013 Physics question on Photoelectric effect and Einstein's equation

Looking at the graphs, you can most appropriately say that:

SOLUTION

In the photoelectric effect, the stopping potential V0V_0 is related to the reciprocal of the wavelength λ\lambda of the incident light. The photoelectric equation is given by:

eV0=hν−ϕeV_0 = h\nu - \phi

where ee is the charge of an electron, hh is Planck's constant, ν\nu is the frequency of the light, and ϕ\phi is the work function of the metal. The frequency ν\nu can be expressed in terms of wavelength λ\lambda using the speed of light cc:

ν=cλ\nu = \frac{c}{\lambda}

Substituting this into the equation:

eV0=h⋅cλ−ϕeV_0 = h \cdot \frac{c}{\lambda} - \phi

Rearranging for V0V_0:

eV0=hcλ−ϕeV_0 = \frac{hc}{\lambda} - \phi

V0=hce⋅1λ−ϕeV_0 = \frac{hc}{e} \cdot \frac{1}{\lambda} - \frac{\phi}{e}

This equation shows that V0V_0 is linearly proportional to 1λ\frac{1}{\lambda}. The slope of the line is hce\frac{hc}{e}, which is a constant because hh, cc, and ee are fundamental constants. Therefore, for any metal, the slope of the graph of V0V_0 versus 1λ\frac{1}{\lambda} must be the same.

When plotting this graph for two different metals A and B, the lines should be parallel because the slope hce\frac{hc}{e} is identical for both. The only difference between the metals is in the work function ϕ\phi, which affects the intercept on the V0V_0-axis (which is −ϕe-\frac{\phi}{e}).

Now, examining the options:

Option A claims that the work function of metal B is greater than that of metal A. Option C claims the opposite. However, without knowing the relative positions of the lines (i.e., which line has a more negative intercept), we cannot determine which metal has a larger work function. Therefore, neither A nor C can be conclusively said.

Option B states that for light of a certain wavelength, the maximum kinetic energy of electrons emitted from metal A is greater than from metal B. The maximum kinetic energy KmaxK_{\text{max}} is given by eV0eV_0, so it depends on the stopping potential. For a fixed wavelength, Kmax=hν−ϕK_{\text{max}} = h\nu - \phi. This means that the metal with the smaller work function will have a larger KmaxK_{\text{max}}. Without knowing which metal has the smaller work function, we cannot say that A will always have a greater KmaxK_{\text{max}} than B. Thus, option B is not necessarily true.

Option D states that the student's data is not correct. Since the slope hce\frac{hc}{e} must be the same for both metals, the graphs should show two parallel lines. If the student's plots show lines with different slopes, this violates the fundamental photoelectric equation, indicating an error in the data or experiment. Therefore, if the graphs are not parallel, the data is incorrect.

Given that the question asks what we can most appropriately say by looking at the graphs, and without specific details on the lines' slopes or intercepts, the only universally applicable statement is that if the slopes differ, the data must be incorrect. Hence, option D is the most appropriate choice.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Photoelectric effect and Einstein's equation. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicPhotoelectric effect and Einstein's equation
TypeMultiple choice