JEE Main 2018 Physics question — de Broglie wavelength of matter waves
Two electrons are moving with non-relativistic speeds perpendicular to each other. If corresponding de Broglie wavelengths are λ1 and λ2, their de Broglie wavelength in the frame of reference attached to their centre of mass is:
SOLUTION
For any particle moving non-relativistically, the de Broglie relation states
λ=ph,
where h is Planck’s constant and p is the linear momentum of the particle.
Let the magnitudes of the momenta of the two electrons in the laboratory frame be p1 and p2. Using the above relation we can write
p1=λ1h,p2=λ2h.
We are told that the velocity vectors of the two electrons are perpendicular to each other. We can choose a convenient set of axes so that
p1=p1i^,p2=p2j^.
The total momentum of the two-electron system is therefore the vector sum
Ptot=p1+p2=p1i^+p2j^.
Its magnitude is obtained from the Pythagorean theorem because the two components are perpendicular:
∣Ptot∣=p12+p22.
The centre-of-mass (CM) velocity of the system is, by definition,
VCM=m1+m2Ptot.
Both particles are electrons, so m1=m2=me, giving
VCM=2mePtot=2mep1i^+2mep2j^.
Now we determine the momentum of, say, electron 1 in the CM frame. The Galilean transformation for momenta at non-relativistic speeds is
p1′=p1−meVCM.
Substituting the expressions for p1 and VCM, we get
Because the two electrons have equal mass, electron 2 possesses the same magnitude of momentum in the CM frame; hence the common CM-frame de Broglie wavelength is
λCM=pCMh=21p12+p22h=p12+p222h.
Next we eliminate the momenta in favour of the given wavelengths. Recalling p1=h/λ1 and p2=h/λ2, we have
p12+p22=(λ1h)2+(λ2h)2=h2(λ121+λ221).
Inserting this into the expression for λCM gives
λCM=hλ121+λ2212h=λ121+λ2212.
To put everything over a common denominator, write
λ121+λ221=λ12λ22λ22+λ12.
Therefore
λ121+λ221=λ1λ2λ12+λ22.
Substituting this result into the previous expression for λCM, we finally reach
λCM=λ1λ2λ12+λ222=λ12+λ222λ1λ2.
This matches option C.
Hence, the correct answer is Option C.
Tagged de Broglie wavelength of matter waves. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.