RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2018 · 15 APR S1+4 / −1HARDTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2018 Physics question — de Broglie wavelength of matter waves

Two electrons are moving with non-relativistic speeds perpendicular to each other. If corresponding de Broglie wavelengths are λ1\lambda_1 and λ2\lambda_2, their de Broglie wavelength in the frame of reference attached to their centre of mass is:

SOLUTION

For any particle moving non-relativistically, the de Broglie relation states

λ=hp,\lambda=\dfrac{h}{p},

where hh is Planck’s constant and pp is the linear momentum of the particle.

Let the magnitudes of the momenta of the two electrons in the laboratory frame be p1p_1 and p2p_2. Using the above relation we can write

p1=hλ1,p2=hλ2.p_1=\dfrac{h}{\lambda_1}, \qquad p_2=\dfrac{h}{\lambda_2}.

We are told that the velocity vectors of the two electrons are perpendicular to each other. We can choose a convenient set of axes so that

p⃗1=p1 i^,p⃗2=p2 j^.\vec p_1=p_1\,\hat i, \qquad \vec p_2=p_2\,\hat j.

The total momentum of the two-electron system is therefore the vector sum

P⃗tot=p⃗1+p⃗2=p1 i^+p2 j^.\vec P_{\text{tot}}=\vec p_1+\vec p_2=p_1\,\hat i+p_2\,\hat j.

Its magnitude is obtained from the Pythagorean theorem because the two components are perpendicular:

∣P⃗tot∣=p1 2+p2 2.|\vec P_{\text{tot}}|=\sqrt{p_1^{\,2}+p_2^{\,2}}.

The centre-of-mass (CM) velocity of the system is, by definition,

V⃗ ⁣CM=P⃗totm1+m2.\vec V_{\!CM}=\dfrac{\vec P_{\text{tot}}}{m_1+m_2}.

Both particles are electrons, so m1=m2=mem_1=m_2=m_e, giving

V⃗ ⁣CM=P⃗tot2me=p12me i^+p22me j^.\vec V_{\!CM}=\dfrac{\vec P_{\text{tot}}}{2m_e} =\dfrac{p_1}{2m_e}\,\hat i+\dfrac{p_2}{2m_e}\,\hat j.

Now we determine the momentum of, say, electron 1 in the CM frame. The Galilean transformation for momenta at non-relativistic speeds is

p⃗1′=p⃗1−meV⃗ ⁣CM.\vec p_1'=\vec p_1-m_e\vec V_{\!CM}.

Substituting the expressions for p⃗1\vec p_1 and V⃗ ⁣CM\vec V_{\!CM}, we get

p⃗1′=p1 i^−me ⁣(p12me i^+p22me j^)=(p1−p12)i^−p22j^=p12 i^−p22 j^.\vec p_1'= p_1\,\hat i- m_e\!\left(\dfrac{p_1}{2m_e}\,\hat i+\dfrac{p_2}{2m_e}\,\hat j\right) =\Bigl(p_1-\dfrac{p_1}{2}\Bigr)\hat i-\dfrac{p_2}{2}\hat j =\dfrac{p_1}{2}\,\hat i-\dfrac{p_2}{2}\,\hat j.

The magnitude of this vector is therefore

p ⁣CM=∣p⃗1′∣=(p12) ⁣2+(p22) ⁣2=12p1 2+p2 2.p_{\!CM}=|\vec p_1'|=\sqrt{\left(\dfrac{p_1}{2}\right)^{\!2}+ \left(\dfrac{p_2}{2}\right)^{\!2}} =\dfrac{1}{2}\sqrt{p_1^{\,2}+p_2^{\,2}}.

Because the two electrons have equal mass, electron 2 possesses the same magnitude of momentum in the CM frame; hence the common CM-frame de Broglie wavelength is

λCM=hp ⁣CM=h12p1 2+p2 2=2hp1 2+p2 2.\lambda_{CM}=\dfrac{h}{p_{\!CM}} =\dfrac{h}{\dfrac{1}{2}\sqrt{p_1^{\,2}+p_2^{\,2}}} =\dfrac{2h}{\sqrt{p_1^{\,2}+p_2^{\,2}}}.

Next we eliminate the momenta in favour of the given wavelengths. Recalling p1=h/λ1p_1=h/\lambda_1 and p2=h/λ2p_2=h/\lambda_2, we have

p1 2+p2 2=(hλ1) ⁣2+(hλ2) ⁣2=h2 ⁣(1λ1 2+1λ2 2).p_1^{\,2}+p_2^{\,2} =\left(\dfrac{h}{\lambda_1}\right)^{\!2}+\left(\dfrac{h}{\lambda_2}\right)^{\!2} =h^{2}\!\left(\dfrac{1}{\lambda_1^{\,2}}+\dfrac{1}{\lambda_2^{\,2}}\right).

Inserting this into the expression for λCM\lambda_{CM} gives

λCM=2hh1λ1 2+1λ2 2=21λ1 2+1λ2 2.\lambda_{CM} =\dfrac{2h} {h\sqrt{\dfrac{1}{\lambda_1^{\,2}}+\dfrac{1}{\lambda_2^{\,2}}}} =\dfrac{2} {\sqrt{\dfrac{1}{\lambda_1^{\,2}}+\dfrac{1}{\lambda_2^{\,2}}}}.

To put everything over a common denominator, write

1λ1 2+1λ2 2=λ2 2+λ1 2λ1 2λ2 2.\dfrac{1}{\lambda_1^{\,2}}+\dfrac{1}{\lambda_2^{\,2}} =\dfrac{\lambda_2^{\,2}+\lambda_1^{\,2}}{\lambda_1^{\,2}\lambda_2^{\,2}}.

Therefore

1λ1 2+1λ2 2=λ1 2+λ2 2λ1λ2.\sqrt{\dfrac{1}{\lambda_1^{\,2}}+\dfrac{1}{\lambda_2^{\,2}}} =\dfrac{\sqrt{\lambda_1^{\,2}+\lambda_2^{\,2}}}{\lambda_1\lambda_2}.

Substituting this result into the previous expression for λCM\lambda_{CM}, we finally reach

λCM=2λ1 2+λ2 2λ1λ2=2λ1λ2λ1 2+λ2 2.\lambda_{CM} =\dfrac{2}{\dfrac{\sqrt{\lambda_1^{\,2}+\lambda_2^{\,2}}}{\lambda_1\lambda_2}} =\dfrac{2\lambda_1\lambda_2}{\sqrt{\lambda_1^{\,2}+\lambda_2^{\,2}}}.

This matches option C.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged de Broglie wavelength of matter waves. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
Topicde Broglie wavelength of matter waves
TypeMultiple choice