RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 09 APR S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Physics question — Motion of centre of mass, momentum conservation and explosions

A wedge of mass M=4mM = 4m lies on a frictionless plane. A particle of mass mm approaches the wedge with speed vv. There is no friction between the particle and the plane or between the particle and the wedge. The maximum height climbed by the particle on the wedge is given by:

SOLUTION

We are told that a wedge of mass MM rests on a perfectly smooth horizontal table and that a small particle of mass mm slides up the wedge without any friction anywhere. Numerically, the wedge is four times heavier than the particle, so M=4mM = 4m. The particle is launched horizontally towards the wedge with speed vv.

Because the horizontal table is friction-free, no external horizontal force acts on the two-body system “particle + wedge”. Therefore the total horizontal linear momentum of the system will remain constant throughout the motion. This is our first key principle:

(i) Conservation of horizontal momentum: Pinitial=PfinalP_{\text{initial}} = P_{\text{final}}.

Secondly, all surfaces are smooth, so no mechanical energy is dissipated as heat. The only potential energy that changes is the gravitational potential energy of the particle as it climbs the wedge. Therefore the total mechanical energy of the system is also conserved:

(ii) Conservation of mechanical energy: Einitial=EfinalE_{\text{initial}} = E_{\text{final}}.

We now apply these two principles step by step.

Initial state (just before contact)
The wedge is at rest, so its horizontal velocity is 00. The particle of mass mm moves towards the wedge with speed vv. Hence

Initial horizontal momentum: Pinitial=m v.P_{\text{initial}} = m\,v.

Initial kinetic energy: Ekin, initial=12 m v2.E_{\text{kin,\,initial}} = \frac12\,m\,v^{2}.

The initial gravitational potential energy of the particle can be taken as zero (reference level at the foot of the wedge).

Final state (highest point reached by the particle on the wedge)
At the highest point the particle is momentarily at rest relative to the wedge. Because both bodies are still free to slide on the table, the particle and the wedge must, at that instant, move together with some common horizontal speed, say uu, relative to the ground. Therefore

Final horizontal momentum: Pfinal=(M+m) u.P_{\text{final}} = (M + m)\,u.

Final kinetic energy: Ekin, final=12 (M+m) u2.E_{\text{kin,\,final}} = \frac12\,(M + m)\,u^{2}.

Let the particle have climbed a vertical height hh on the wedge. Its gain in gravitational potential energy is then

Epot, gain=m g h.E_{\text{pot,\,gain}} = m\,g\,h.

We now write the conservation equations explicitly.

Step 1 : Linear momentum conservation

m v=(M+m) u.m\,v = (M + m)\,u.

We solve this for uu:

u=m vM+m.u = \frac{m\,v}{M + m}.

Given M=4mM = 4m, we substitute:

u=m v4m+m=m v5m=v5.u = \frac{m\,v}{4m + m} = \frac{m\,v}{5m} = \frac{v}{5}.

Step 2 : Mechanical energy conservation

Initial total energy = Final total energy:

12 m v2=12 (M+m) u2+m g h.\frac12\,m\,v^{2} = \frac12\,(M + m)\,u^{2} + m\,g\,h.

First we insert M+m=4m+m=5mM + m = 4m + m = 5m and u=v5u = \dfrac{v}{5}:

12 m v2=12 (5m)(v5)2+m g h.\frac12\,m\,v^{2} = \frac12\,(5m)\left(\frac{v}{5}\right)^{2} + m\,g\,h.

We now simplify term by term. Start with the kinetic term on the right:

(v5)2=v225,\left(\frac{v}{5}\right)^{2} = \frac{v^{2}}{25},

so

12 (5m)(v225)=12×5m×v225=5m v250=m v210.\frac12\,(5m)\left(\frac{v^{2}}{25}\right) = \frac12 \times 5m \times \frac{v^{2}}{25} = \frac{5m\,v^{2}}{50} = \frac{m\,v^{2}}{10}.

Our energy equation is now

12 m v2=m v210+m g h.\frac12\,m\,v^{2} = \frac{m\,v^{2}}{10} + m\,g\,h.

To clear the fractions, multiply every term by 2m\dfrac{2}{m} (this also cancels the common factor mm):

v2=2m×m v210+2 g h    ⟹    v2=2 v210+2 g h.v^{2} = \frac{2}{m}\times\frac{m\,v^{2}}{10} + 2\,g\,h \;\;\Longrightarrow\;\; v^{2} = \frac{2\,v^{2}}{10} + 2\,g\,h.

Simplify the first term on the right:

2 v210=v25.\frac{2\,v^{2}}{10} = \frac{v^{2}}{5}.

Hence

v2=v25+2 g h.v^{2} = \frac{v^{2}}{5} + 2\,g\,h.

Subtract v25\dfrac{v^{2}}{5} from both sides:

v2−v25=2 g h.v^{2} - \frac{v^{2}}{5} = 2\,g\,h.

Write the left side with a common denominator:

5v25−v25=4v25.\frac{5v^{2}}{5} - \frac{v^{2}}{5} = \frac{4v^{2}}{5}.

Thus

4v25=2 g h.\frac{4v^{2}}{5} = 2\,g\,h.

Finally, solve for hh by dividing both sides by 2g2g:

h=4v252g=4v210g=2v25g.h = \frac{\frac{4v^{2}}{5}}{2g} = \frac{4v^{2}}{10g} = \frac{2v^{2}}{5g}.

We have reached an explicit expression for the maximum height climbed by the particle. Comparing with the options given, this corresponds to Option C.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Motion of centre of mass, momentum conservation and explosions. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicMotion of centre of mass, momentum conservation and explosions
TypeMultiple choice