RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 08 JAN S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Physics question — Centre of mass of continuous bodies and cavities

As shown in figure. When a spherical cavity (centred at O) of radius 1 is cut out of a uniform sphere of radius R (centred at C), the centre of mass of remaining (shaded part of sphere is at G, i.e., on the surface of the cavity. R can be determined by the equation:

Figure for JEE Main 2020 Physics question on Centre of mass of continuous bodies and cavities
SOLUTION

Let us denote the uniform mass-density of the material by ρ\rho.

We first write the masses of the two spheres explicitly. For the big sphere (centre at CC, radius RR)

Mbig=4π3ρR3M_{\text{big}}=\dfrac{4\pi}{3}\rho R^{3}

and for the cavity (centre at OO, radius 11)

Mcav=4π3ρ  13=4π3ρ.M_{\text{cav}}=\dfrac{4\pi}{3}\rho \;1^{3}= \dfrac{4\pi}{3}\rho.

The mass of the remaining (shaded) solid is therefore

Mrem=Mbig−Mcav=4π3ρ(R3−1).M_{\text{rem}}=M_{\text{big}}-M_{\text{cav}}=\dfrac{4\pi}{3}\rho\left(R^{3}-1\right).

Because the situation is completely symmetrical about the straight line COCO, the centre of mass of the remainder must lie somewhere on this very line. We choose the origin of the one-dimensional coordinate axis at OO and measure every distance along OCOC as positive. With this choice

xO=0,xC=d  (=  OC).x_{O}=0,\qquad x_{C}=d \;(=\;OC).

The point GG, by statement of the problem, is situated on the surface of the cavity, that is exactly one unit away from OO along the same line, so

xG=1.x_{G}=1.

Now we invoke the centre-of-mass formula for a composite body:

Mrem  xG=Mbig  xC−Mcav  xO.M_{\text{rem}}\;x_{G}=M_{\text{big}}\;x_{C}-M_{\text{cav}}\;x_{O}.

Substituting the known quantities, we have

[4π3ρ(R3−1)](1)=[4π3ρR3] d−[4π3ρ](0).\left[\dfrac{4\pi}{3}\rho\left(R^{3}-1\right)\right](1)=\left[\dfrac{4\pi}{3}\rho R^{3}\right]\,d-\left[\dfrac{4\pi}{3}\rho\right](0).

All common factors 4π3ρ\dfrac{4\pi}{3}\rho cancel immediately, leaving the simple relation

R3−1=R3 d⟹d=R3−1R3=1−1R3.R^{3}-1=R^{3}\,d\qquad\Longrightarrow\qquad d=\dfrac{R^{3}-1}{R^{3}}=1-\dfrac{1}{R^{3}}.

Up to this point, every value of R>1R>1 would merely give a different permissible separation dd of the two centres. However, the drawing that accompanies the question shows the cavity touching the outer surface of the large sphere at a single point. For two spheres of radii RR (big) and 11 (cavity) this “tangential” condition means quite simply

OC+1=R⟹d=R−1.OC+1=R\qquad\Longrightarrow\qquad d=R-1.

Putting this geometric condition together with the mass-balance condition just obtained we write

1−1R3=R−1.1-\dfrac{1}{R^{3}}=R-1.

Rearranging,

2−R−1R3=0⟹1=R3(2−R).2-R-\dfrac{1}{R^{3}}=0\qquad\Longrightarrow\qquad 1=R^{3}(2-R).

We still have the factor R3R^{3} on the right. It is convenient to eliminate it by first observing from an earlier step that

R3−1=R3(R−1).R^{3}-1=R^{3}(R-1).

Dividing both members of this identity by R−1R-1 (with R≠1R\neq1) we get the well-known algebraic result

R3=R2+R+1.R^{3}=R^{2}+R+1.

Substituting this expression for R3R^{3} in the equation 1=R3(2−R)1=R^{3}(2-R) leads directly to

1=(R2+R+1)(2−R).1=(R^{2}+R+1)(2-R).

Exactly the same algebra appears, term for term, in option A, viz.

(R2+R+1)(2−R)=1.(R^{2}+R+1)(2-R)=1.

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Centre of mass of continuous bodies and cavities. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicCentre of mass of continuous bodies and cavities
TypeMultiple choice