RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2013 · 07 APR ONLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2013 Physics question — Head-on collisions and coefficient of restitution

This question has Statement - I and Statement - II. Of the four choices given after the Statements, choose the one that best describes the two Statements.
Statement - I: A point particle of mass mm moving with speed vv collides with stationary point particle of mass MM. If the maximum energy loss possible is given as f(12mv2)f\left(\frac{1}{2}mv^2\right) then f=(mM+m)f = \left(\frac{m}{M+m}\right).
Statement - II: Maximum energy loss occurs when the particles get stuck together as a result of the collision.

SOLUTION

We have a one-dimensional situation in which a point particle of mass mm is moving with speed vv and strikes another point particle of mass MM that is initially at rest. The kinetic energy before collision is therefore

Kinitial=12 m v2.K_{\text{initial}}=\dfrac12\,m\,v^{2}.

Linear momentum is conserved in every type of collision, so the total initial momentum is

pinitial=m v.p_{\text{initial}} = m\,v.

Statement II tells us that the greatest possible loss of kinetic energy occurs when the two particles stick together. Such a collision is called a perfectly inelastic collision. We now analyse this perfectly inelastic case in detail.

After sticking, the two particles move as a single composite body of mass m+Mm+M with some common speed V.V. By conservation of linear momentum,

pinitial=pfinal,som v=(m+M) V.p_{\text{initial}} = p_{\text{final}}, \qquad\text{so}\qquad m\,v = (m+M)\,V.

Hence,

V=m vm+M.V = \dfrac{m\,v}{m+M}.

The kinetic energy after the collision is

Kfinal=12 (m+M) V2.K_{\text{final}} = \dfrac12\,(m+M)\,V^{2}.

Substituting the value of VV obtained above, we get

Kfinal=12 (m+M)(m vm+M)2=12 (m+M) m2 v2(m+M)2=12 m2 v2m+M.\begin{aligned} K_{\text{final}} &= \dfrac12\,(m+M)\left(\dfrac{m\,v}{m+M}\right)^{2} \\ &= \dfrac12\,(m+M)\,\dfrac{m^{2}\,v^{2}}{(m+M)^{2}} \\ &= \dfrac12\,\dfrac{m^{2}\,v^{2}}{m+M}. \end{aligned}

The loss of kinetic energy, ΔK,\Delta K, is the difference between the initial and final kinetic energies:

ΔK=Kinitial−Kfinal=12 m v2  −  12 m2 v2m+M.\begin{aligned} \Delta K &= K_{\text{initial}} - K_{\text{final}} \\ &= \dfrac12\,m\,v^{2} \;-\; \dfrac12\,\dfrac{m^{2}\,v^{2}}{m+M}. \end{aligned}

We now factor out the common factor 12 m v2:\dfrac12\,m\,v^{2}:

ΔK=12 m v2[1−mm+M].\begin{aligned} \Delta K &= \dfrac12\,m\,v^{2}\left[1 - \dfrac{m}{m+M}\right]. \end{aligned}

Simplifying the bracket,

1−mm+M=m+Mm+M−mm+M=m+M−mm+M=Mm+M.\begin{aligned} 1 - \dfrac{m}{m+M} &= \dfrac{m+M}{m+M} - \dfrac{m}{m+M} \\ &= \dfrac{m+M - m}{m+M} \\ &= \dfrac{M}{m+M}. \end{aligned}

Therefore, the maximum possible loss of kinetic energy is

ΔKmax⁡=12 m v2(Mm+M).\Delta K_{\max} = \dfrac12\,m\,v^{2}\left(\dfrac{M}{m+M}\right).

Comparing this result with the form stated in Statement I, namely f(12 m v2),f\left(\dfrac12\,m\,v^{2}\right), we see that

f=Mm+M,f = \dfrac{M}{m+M},

whereas Statement I claims f=mM+m.f = \dfrac{m}{M+m}. Hence Statement I is false.

Statement II, asserting that maximum energy loss occurs when the particles stick together, is exactly what we have used above; it is therefore true.

Combining these conclusions, we find that Statement I is false while Statement II is true. This matches Option B in the list provided.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Head-on collisions and coefficient of restitution. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicHead-on collisions and coefficient of restitution
TypeMultiple choice