We have the four numbers 2 , 3 , a , 11 2,\;3,\;a,\;11 2 , 3 , a , 11 . Their arithmetic mean is obtained from the formula for the mean of n n n observations, μ = sum of the observations n \mu=\dfrac{\text{sum of the observations}}{n} μ = n sum of the observations . Here n = 4 n=4 n = 4 , so
μ = 2 + 3 + a + 11 4 = 16 + a 4 = a + 16 4 . \mu=\dfrac{2+3+a+11}{4}
=\dfrac{16+a}{4}
=\dfrac{a+16}{4}. μ = 4 2 + 3 + a + 11 = 4 16 + a = 4 a + 16 .
The standard deviation σ \sigma σ of a set of four (population) values is defined by
σ = ( x 1 − μ ) 2 + ( x 2 − μ ) 2 + ( x 3 − μ ) 2 + ( x 4 − μ ) 2 4 , \sigma=\sqrt{\dfrac
{(x_1-\mu)^2+(x_2-\mu)^2+(x_3-\mu)^2+(x_4-\mu)^2}{4}}, σ = 4 ( x 1 − μ ) 2 + ( x 2 − μ ) 2 + ( x 3 − μ ) 2 + ( x 4 − μ ) 2 ,
and its square, the variance, is therefore
σ 2 = ( x 1 − μ ) 2 + ( x 2 − μ ) 2 + ( x 3 − μ ) 2 + ( x 4 − μ ) 2 4 . \sigma^2=\dfrac
{(x_1-\mu)^2+(x_2-\mu)^2+(x_3-\mu)^2+(x_4-\mu)^2}{4}. σ 2 = 4 ( x 1 − μ ) 2 + ( x 2 − μ ) 2 + ( x 3 − μ ) 2 + ( x 4 − μ ) 2 .
We are told that σ = 3.5 \sigma=3.5 σ = 3.5 , so σ 2 = ( 3.5 ) 2 = 12.25 = 49 4 \sigma^2=(3.5)^2=12.25=\dfrac{49}{4} σ 2 = ( 3.5 ) 2 = 12.25 = 4 49 .
Now let us write each squared deviation.
First deviation:
2 − μ = 2 − a + 16 4 = 8 − a − 16 4 = − a + 8 4 , ( 2 − μ ) 2 = ( a + 8 ) 2 16 . 2-\mu=2-\dfrac{a+16}{4}=\dfrac{8-a-16}{4}=-\dfrac{a+8}{4},
\qquad
(2-\mu)^2=\dfrac{(a+8)^2}{16}. 2 − μ = 2 − 4 a + 16 = 4 8 − a − 16 = − 4 a + 8 , ( 2 − μ ) 2 = 16 ( a + 8 ) 2 .
Second deviation:
3 − μ = 3 − a + 16 4 = 12 − a − 16 4 = − a + 4 4 , ( 3 − μ ) 2 = ( a + 4 ) 2 16 . 3-\mu=3-\dfrac{a+16}{4}=\dfrac{12-a-16}{4}=-\dfrac{a+4}{4},
\qquad
(3-\mu)^2=\dfrac{(a+4)^2}{16}. 3 − μ = 3 − 4 a + 16 = 4 12 − a − 16 = − 4 a + 4 , ( 3 − μ ) 2 = 16 ( a + 4 ) 2 .
Third deviation:
a − μ = a − a + 16 4 = 4 a − a − 16 4 = 3 a − 16 4 , ( a − μ ) 2 = ( 3 a − 16 ) 2 16 . a-\mu=a-\dfrac{a+16}{4}=\dfrac{4a-a-16}{4}=\dfrac{3a-16}{4},
\qquad
(a-\mu)^2=\dfrac{(3a-16)^2}{16}. a − μ = a − 4 a + 16 = 4 4 a − a − 16 = 4 3 a − 16 , ( a − μ ) 2 = 16 ( 3 a − 16 ) 2 .
Fourth deviation:
11 − μ = 11 − a + 16 4 = 44 − a − 16 4 = 28 − a 4 , ( 11 − μ ) 2 = ( 28 − a ) 2 16 . 11-\mu=11-\dfrac{a+16}{4}=\dfrac{44-a-16}{4}=\dfrac{28-a}{4},
\qquad
(11-\mu)^2=\dfrac{(28-a)^2}{16}. 11 − μ = 11 − 4 a + 16 = 4 44 − a − 16 = 4 28 − a , ( 11 − μ ) 2 = 16 ( 28 − a ) 2 .
Adding the four squared deviations gives
( 2 − μ ) 2 + ( 3 − μ ) 2 + ( a − μ ) 2 + ( 11 − μ ) 2 = ( a + 8 ) 2 16 + ( a + 4 ) 2 16 + ( 3 a − 16 ) 2 16 + ( 28 − a ) 2 16 = ( a + 8 ) 2 + ( a + 4 ) 2 + ( 3 a − 16 ) 2 + ( 28 − a ) 2 16 . \begin{aligned}
&(2-\mu)^2+(3-\mu)^2+(a-\mu)^2+(11-\mu)^2 \\[4pt]
&=\dfrac{(a+8)^2}{16}+\dfrac{(a+4)^2}{16}+\dfrac{(3a-16)^2}{16}+\dfrac{(28-a)^2}{16} \\[4pt]
&=\dfrac{(a+8)^2+(a+4)^2+(3a-16)^2+(28-a)^2}{16}.
\end{aligned} ( 2 − μ ) 2 + ( 3 − μ ) 2 + ( a − μ ) 2 + ( 11 − μ ) 2 = 16 ( a + 8 ) 2 + 16 ( a + 4 ) 2 + 16 ( 3 a − 16 ) 2 + 16 ( 28 − a ) 2 = 16 ( a + 8 ) 2 + ( a + 4 ) 2 + ( 3 a − 16 ) 2 + ( 28 − a ) 2 .
Placing this expression into the variance formula we get
σ 2 = 1 4 × ( a + 8 ) 2 + ( a + 4 ) 2 + ( 3 a − 16 ) 2 + ( 28 − a ) 2 16 = ( a + 8 ) 2 + ( a + 4 ) 2 + ( 3 a − 16 ) 2 + ( 28 − a ) 2 64 . \sigma^2=\dfrac{1}{4}\times\dfrac{(a+8)^2+(a+4)^2+(3a-16)^2+(28-a)^2}{16}
=\dfrac{(a+8)^2+(a+4)^2+(3a-16)^2+(28-a)^2}{64}. σ 2 = 4 1 × 16 ( a + 8 ) 2 + ( a + 4 ) 2 + ( 3 a − 16 ) 2 + ( 28 − a ) 2 = 64 ( a + 8 ) 2 + ( a + 4 ) 2 + ( 3 a − 16 ) 2 + ( 28 − a ) 2 .
Since σ 2 = 49 4 \sigma^2=\dfrac{49}{4} σ 2 = 4 49 , we equate the two expressions:
( a + 8 ) 2 + ( a + 4 ) 2 + ( 3 a − 16 ) 2 + ( 28 − a ) 2 64 = 49 4 . \dfrac{(a+8)^2+(a+4)^2+(3a-16)^2+(28-a)^2}{64}=\dfrac{49}{4}. 64 ( a + 8 ) 2 + ( a + 4 ) 2 + ( 3 a − 16 ) 2 + ( 28 − a ) 2 = 4 49 .
Multiplying both sides by 64 64 64 produces
( a + 8 ) 2 + ( a + 4 ) 2 + ( 3 a − 16 ) 2 + ( 28 − a ) 2 = 64 × 49 4 = 16 × 49 = 784. (a+8)^2+(a+4)^2+(3a-16)^2+(28-a)^2=64\times\dfrac{49}{4}=16\times49=784. ( a + 8 ) 2 + ( a + 4 ) 2 + ( 3 a − 16 ) 2 + ( 28 − a ) 2 = 64 × 4 49 = 16 × 49 = 784.
Now expand every square and collect like terms:
\begin{aligned}
(a+8)^2 &= a^2+16a+64 , \\
(a+4)^2 &= a^2 \;+\; 8a \;+\;16 , \\
(3a-16)^2 &= 9a^2-96a+256 , \\
(28-a)^2 &= a^2-56a+784.
\end{aligned}
Adding them yields
\begin{aligned}
&[a^2+16a+64]+\ , [a^2+8a+16]+\ , [9a^2-96a+256]+\ , [a^2-56a+784] \\[4pt]
&=(a^2+a^2+9a^2+a^2)+(16a+8a-96a-56a)+(64+16+256+784) \\[4pt]
&=12a^2-128a+1120.
\end{aligned}
Equating this sum to 784 784 784 gives
12 a 2 − 128 a + 1120 = 784. 12a^2-128a+1120=784. 12 a 2 − 128 a + 1120 = 784.
Subtracting 784 784 784 from both sides, we obtain
12 a 2 − 128 a + 336 = 0. 12a^2-128a+336=0. 12 a 2 − 128 a + 336 = 0.
Dividing every term by 4 4 4 simplifies the quadratic to
3 a 2 − 32 a + 84 = 0. 3a^2-32a+84=0. 3 a 2 − 32 a + 84 = 0.
This relation matches Option D, which is written exactly as 3 a 2 − 32 a + 84 = 0 3a^2 - 32a + 84 = 0 3 a 2 − 32 a + 84 = 0 .
Hence, the correct answer is Option D.