In a box, there are 20 cards, out of which 10 are labelled as and the remaining 10 are labelled as . Cards are drawn at random, one after the other and with replacement, till a second card is obtained. The probability that the second card appears before the third card is:
We begin by noting that at every draw the probability of getting an is and, similarly, the probability of getting a is also . Because the card is replaced after each draw, each trial is independent and the two probabilities remain constant throughout the experiment.
We have to keep drawing cards until the second appears. During this process a third may or may not appear. We are asked to find the probability that the second comes before the third . In other words, we must calculate the probability that two ’s are obtained earlier than three ’s in an infinite sequence of independent trials with .
To attack such “race” problems systematically, we introduce a state variable. Let
P(i,j)=\text{Probability that the second }A\text{ beats the third }B\text{ when }i\text{’s and }j\text{’s have already been drawn.}$
At the start of the experiment no card has been recorded, so we ultimately want .
There are obvious boundary states:
• If we ever reach (two ’s) we have already succeeded, so
• If we ever reach (three ’s) before the second , we have failed, so
For an interior state with and , the next draw can be either or . Using the Law of Total Probability we write the recursion
$
Now we solve these equations step by step, beginning with states closest to the boundaries and working backwards to
1. State
Exactly one and two ’s have already appeared.
Next draw:
• with probability state (success).
• with probability state (failure).
Hence
2. State
No yet, two ’s so far.
Next draw:
• .
• (failure).
Thus $
3. State
One and one so far.
Next draw:
• (success).
• .
Hence $
4. State
No and one so far.
Next draw:
• .
• .
Therefore $
5. State
One and no yet.
Next draw:
• (success).
• .
Thus $
6. Starting state
No and no have been drawn yet.
Next draw:
• .
• .
Therefore $
So the probability that the second appears before the third is .
Hence, the correct answer is Option B.
Tagged Classical probability and sample spaces. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.