RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2016 · 03 APR OFFLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2016 Mathematics question — Conditional probability and multiplication theorem

Let two fair six-faced dice AA and BB be thrown simultaneously. If E1E_1 is the event that die AA shows up four, E2E_2 is the event that die BB shows up two and E3E_3 is the event that the sum of numbers on both dice is odd, then which of the following statements is not true?

SOLUTION

We begin by noting that each of the two dice is fair and six-faced, so the ordered pairs of outcomes (A,B)=(1,1),(1,2),…,(6,6)\bigl(A,B\bigr)=(1,1),(1,2),\dots,(6,6) are all equally likely. There are in total 6×6=366\times 6=36 such pairs, each having probability 136\dfrac1{36}.

The three events are defined as follows:

E1:  A=4,E2:  B=2,E3:  A+B is odd.E_1:\;A=4,\qquad E_2:\;B=2,\qquad E_3:\;A+B\text{ is odd.}

First, we compute the individual probabilities.

For E1E_1 we require the first die to show four. The second die may show any of the six numbers, giving 66 favourable pairs: (4,1),(4,2),(4,3),(4,4),(4,5),(4,6).(4,1),(4,2),(4,3),(4,4),(4,5),(4,6). Hence P(E1)=636=16.P(E_1)=\dfrac6{36}=\dfrac16. Exactly the same reasoning applies to E2E_2, so P(E2)=16.P(E_2)=\dfrac16. For E3E_3, the sum is odd exactly when one die is even and the other odd. There are 33 even numbers and 33 odd numbers on a die, so the number of favourable pairs is 3×3+3×3=18.3\times 3+3\times 3=18. Thus P(E3)=1836=12.P(E_3)=\dfrac{18}{36}=\dfrac12.

Now we examine pairwise intersections in order to check pairwise independence.

Intersection of E1E_1 and E2E_2. Both A=4A=4 and B=2B=2 must hold, leaving the single outcome (4,2).(4,2). Therefore P(E1∩E2)=136,P(E1) P(E2)=16⋅16=136.P(E_1\cap E_2)=\dfrac1{36},\qquad P(E_1)\,P(E_2)=\dfrac16\cdot\dfrac16=\dfrac1{36}. Because these two numbers are equal, E1E_1 and E2E_2 are independent.

Intersection of E1E_1 and E3E_3. We already have A=4A=4 (an even number). For the sum to be odd, BB must be odd, i.e. B=1,3,5.B=1,3,5. The three favourable outcomes are (4,1),(4,3),(4,5).(4,1),(4,3),(4,5). Thus P(E1∩E3)=336=112,P(E1) P(E3)=16⋅12=112.P(E_1\cap E_3)=\dfrac3{36}=\dfrac1{12},\qquad P(E_1)\,P(E_3)=\dfrac16\cdot\dfrac12=\dfrac1{12}. The equality confirms that E1E_1 and E3E_3 are independent.

Intersection of E2E_2 and E3E_3. Now B=2B=2 (even), and we need the sum to be odd, so AA must be odd: A=1,3,5.A=1,3,5. The three favourable pairs are (1,2),(3,2),(5,2).(1,2),(3,2),(5,2). Hence P(E2∩E3)=336=112,P(E2) P(E3)=16⋅12=112.P(E_2\cap E_3)=\dfrac3{36}=\dfrac1{12},\qquad P(E_2)\,P(E_3)=\dfrac16\cdot\dfrac12=\dfrac1{12}. Again the two values match, so E2E_2 and E3E_3 are independent.

So far, every pair of events is independent. To see whether all three events are mutually independent, we must consider the triple intersection.

Intersection of E1,E_1, E2,E_2, and E3E_3. Imposing A=4A=4 and B=2B=2 fixes the only possible outcome to be (4,2).(4,2). However, for this outcome the sum is 4+2=6,4+2=6, which is even, not odd. Therefore no single ordered pair satisfies all three conditions simultaneously, and P(E1∩E2∩E3)=0.P(E_1\cap E_2\cap E_3)=0. On the other hand, P(E1) P(E2) P(E3)=16⋅16⋅12=172.P(E_1)\,P(E_2)\,P(E_3)=\dfrac16\cdot\dfrac16\cdot\dfrac12=\dfrac1{72}. Because 0≠172,0\neq\dfrac1{72}, the three events E1,E2,E3E_1,E_2,E_3 are not mutually independent.

We have now gathered all the information required to assess the given statements:

  • Statement A: “E1E_1 and E3E_3 are independent.” — True.
  • Statement B: “E1E_1, E2E_2 and E3E_3 are independent.” — Not true (they are not mutually independent).
  • Statement C: “E1E_1 and E2E_2 are independent.” — True.
  • Statement D: “E2E_2 and E3E_3 are independent.” — True.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Conditional probability and multiplication theorem. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

TopicConditional probability and multiplication theorem
TypeMultiple choice