Given below are two statements:
Statement I: solid undergoes disproportionation reaction under alkaline conditions to form and
Statement II: can undergo disproportionation reaction under acidic condition.
In the light of the above statements, choose the most appropriate answer from the options given below:
We need to evaluate two statements about disproportionation reactions.
A disproportionation reaction is one where the same element is simultaneously oxidized and reduced — it goes to both a higher and a lower oxidation state.
Statement I asserts that solid undergoes a disproportionation reaction under alkaline conditions to form and . In elemental sulfur , sulfur has oxidation state 0. In , its oxidation state is (reduction), and in (thiosulfate), the average oxidation state of sulfur is (oxidation). Since sulfur in state 0 simultaneously goes to and , this is indeed a disproportionation reaction. The reaction with NaOH can be written as:
Thus, Statement I is correct.
Statement II claims that can undergo disproportionation under acidic conditions. In (perchlorate), chlorine is in the oxidation state, which is the highest possible for chlorine. Disproportionation requires simultaneous oxidation and reduction, but chlorine at cannot be further oxidized. Therefore, cannot undergo disproportionation, making Statement II incorrect.
The correct answer is Option A: Statement I is correct but Statement II is incorrect.
Tagged Oxidising/reducing agents and types of redox reactions. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.