The unbalanced ionic equation given in the question is
MnO4−+C2O42−+H+⟶Mn2++CO2+H2O
We have to find the smallest whole-number coefficients X,Y and Z for MnO4−,C2O42− and H+ respectively that balance the above redox reaction in acidic medium.
Step 1 : Write the two half-reactions.
Reduction half-reaction (permanganate):
MnO4−→Mn2+
Oxidation half-reaction (oxalate):
C2O42−→CO2
Step 2 : Balance each half-reaction separately.
(a) Reduction half-reaction
• Balance Mn: already 1 on each side.
• Balance O by adding H2O: MnO4−→Mn2++4H2O
• Balance H by adding H+: MnO4−+8H+→Mn2++4H2O
• Balance charge by adding electrons: LHS charge =−1+8=+7, RHS charge =+2. Add 5 e⁻ to the left:
MnO4−+8H++5e−→Mn2++4H2O−(1)
(b) Oxidation half-reaction
• Balance C: already 2 on LHS, 1 on RHS ⇒ write 2 CO₂ on RHS:
C2O42−→2CO2
• O already balanced (4 each side).
• No H atoms are involved.
• Balance charge by adding electrons: LHS charge =−2, RHS charge =0, so add 2 e⁻ to RHS:
C2O42−→2CO2+2e−−(2)
Step 3 : Equalise electrons and add the two half-reactions.
The reduction step involves 5 e⁻; the oxidation step, 2 e⁻. The least common multiple of 5 and 2 is 10, so multiply equation (1) by 2 and equation (2) by 5.
2[MnO4−+8H++5e−5[C2O42−→Mn2++4H2O]→2CO2+2e−]
After multiplication:
Reduction (×2): 2MnO4−+16H++10e−→2Mn2++8H2O
Oxidation (×5): 5C2O42−→10CO2+10e−
Step 4 : Add and cancel electrons.
2MnO4−+16H++10e−+5C2O42−⟶2Mn2++8H2O+10CO2+10e−
The 10 e⁻ on both sides cancel exactly, giving the balanced net ionic equation:
2MnO4−+5C2O42−+16H+⟶2Mn2++10CO2+8H2O
Step 5 : Read off the required coefficients.
The coefficients of MnO4−,C2O42− and H+ are respectively X=2,Y=5,Z=16.
Hence, the correct option is:
Option A which is: 2,5,16.