To determine the number of electrons involved in the redox reaction, we first need to balance the reaction since it is given unbalanced. The reaction is:
Cr2O72−+Fe2++C2O42−→Cr3++Fe3++CO2
We start by identifying the oxidation states of each element:
- In Cr2O72−, oxygen is −2. Let the oxidation state of Cr be x. Then 2x+7(−2)=−2, so 2x−14=−2, giving 2x=12, and x=+6. Thus, Cr is +6.
- In Fe2+, iron is +2.
- In C2O42−, oxygen is −2. Let the oxidation state of C be y. Then 2y+4(−2)=−2, so 2y−8=−2, giving 2y=6, and y=+3. Thus, each carbon is +3.
- In Cr3+, chromium is +3.
- In Fe3+, iron is +3.
- In CO2, oxygen is −2, so carbon is +4.
Now, observe the changes in oxidation states:
- Chromium is reduced from +6 to +3, gaining electrons.
- Iron is oxidized from +2 to +3, losing electrons.
- Carbon in oxalate is oxidized from +3 to +4, losing electrons.
We split the reaction into half-reactions:
Reduction: Cr2O72−→Cr3+
Oxidation: Fe2+→Fe3+ and C2O42−→CO2
Balance the reduction half-reaction in acidic medium:
- Balance Cr atoms: Cr2O72−→2Cr3+.
- Balance oxygen by adding water: Cr2O72−→2Cr3++7H2O.
- Balance hydrogen by adding H⁺: Cr2O72−+14H+→2Cr3++7H2O.
- Balance charge: Left side charge is −2+14(+1)=+12, right side is 2(+3)=+6. Add 6 electrons to the left: Cr2O72−+14H++6e−→2Cr3++7H2O.
So, reduction involves 6 electrons per Cr2O72− ion.
Balance the oxidation half-reactions:
- For iron: Fe2+→Fe3++e−. Each Fe2+ loses 1 electron.
- For oxalate: C2O42−→2CO2. Oxidation state change: Two carbons go from +3 to +4, so total loss of 2 electrons. Balance atoms and charge: Left has charge −2, right has charge 0. Add 2 electrons to the right: C2O42−→2CO2+2e−. Each C2O42− loses 2 electrons.
Now, combine the half-reactions. Let the number of Cr2O72− ions be a, Fe2+ ions be b, and C2O42− ions be c.
Electron balance: Electrons gained = electrons lost. Reduction gains 6a electrons. Oxidation loses b electrons from iron and 2c electrons from oxalate. So:
6a=b+2c
The balanced reaction must include H⁺ and H₂O. Using the reduction half-reaction, for each Cr2O72−, we need 14H⁺ and produce 7H₂O. The full reaction is:
aCr2O72−+bFe2++cC2O42−+14aH+→2aCr3++bFe3++2cCO2+7aH2O
Balance atoms and charge:
- Oxygen: Left has 7a+4c atoms (from Cr2O72− and C2O42−), right has 7a from H₂O and 4c from CO₂ (since each CO₂ has 2 oxygen atoms, and 2c CO₂ has 4c oxygen atoms). So 7a+4c=7a+4c, balanced.
- Hydrogen: Left has 14a H atoms from H⁺, right has 14a H atoms from 7a H₂O, balanced.
- Charge: Left charge is −2a+2b−2c+14a=12a+2b−2c. Right charge is 2a×3+b×3=6a+3b. Set equal: 12a+2b−2c=6a+3b, simplifying to 6a−b−2c=0, or b+2c=6a, which matches the electron balance equation.
Solve b+2c=6a for positive integers a, b, c. Since the unbalanced reaction shows one of each reactant, we find minimal solutions:
- If a=1, then b+2c=6. Possible pairs: (b,c)=(4,1) or (2,2).
Both are valid balanced equations:
- For (a,b,c)=(1,4,1): Cr2O72−+4Fe2++C2O42−+14H+→2Cr3++4Fe3++2CO2+7H2O
- For (a,b,c)=(1,2,2): Cr2O72−+2Fe2++2C2O42−+14H+→2Cr3++2Fe3++4CO2+7H2O
In both cases, the total electrons transferred are 6, as reduction gains 6 electrons and oxidation loses 6 electrons:
- Case 1: Iron loses 4×1=4 electrons, oxalate loses 1×2=2 electrons, total 6.
- Case 2: Iron loses 2×1=2 electrons, oxalate loses 2×2=4 electrons, total 6.
The number of electrons involved is always 6 per mole of Cr2O72−, regardless of the coefficients chosen for the reducing agents.
Hence, the correct answer is Option A.