An element X shows +3, oxidation state in its compounds. Out of the four compounds given below, choose the incorrect formula for the element X.
First of all, we are told that the unknown element always exhibits an oxidation state of in all its compounds.
Whenever we write a stable chemical formula, the algebraic sum of all the charges present in the whole formula must be zero, because a compound as a whole is electrically neutral. That is,
We shall now test each of the four given formulae one by one, using the above neutrality requirement and the fact that the oxidation state of is .
Option A:
• Each oxygen atom almost always has the oxidation state
• There are oxygen atoms, so the total negative charge contributed by oxygen is
• Let the oxidation state of each be (as given). There are atoms of so their total positive charge is
• Adding the two totals gives
Since the overall charge is zero, the formula is perfectly acceptable for an element having a state.
Option B:
• The sulphate ion possesses a charge of
• There are sulphate ions, hence the total negative charge from all the sulphate ions equals
• Again, each is in the state, and there are such atoms, so the total positive charge is
• Adding the two totals gives
The neutrality condition is satisfied, therefore is also a correct formula for an element with oxidation state
Option C:
• The phosphate ion carries a charge of
• There is only one phosphate ion present, so the total negative charge is simply
• The compound contains one atom of each of which is so the total positive charge is
The sum of the charges is
hence the formula is perfectly compatible with
Option D:
• Chlorine (in chloride) has the oxidation state
• There are chloride ions, so their total negative charge is
• Each is still and there are such atoms, giving a total positive charge of
• Adding the two totals gives
This sum is not zero; it equals which means the formula is not electrically neutral. Hence this compound cannot exist if is strictly in the oxidation state.
All the other three options satisfy charge neutrality, but Option D does not. Hence, the correct answer is Option D.
Tagged Oxidation number. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.