RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2021 · 31 AUG S2+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2021 Chemistry question — Group 17: halogens and hydrogen halides

Which one of the following correctly represents the order of stability of oxides, X2_2O; (X = halogen)?

SOLUTION

We have to compare the relative stability of the monoxides X2O\mathrm{X_2O} in which the halogen atom X is present in the +1+1 oxidation state. The factors that mainly decide the stability are

1. The ease with which the halogen can exist in a positive oxidation state.
2. The strength of the X-O bond that actually holds the molecule together.

First, let us examine the ease of attaining the +1+1 state. For a halogen the tendency to show positive oxidation states increases as its electronegativity decreases, because a less-electronegative atom can more readily part with electron density to oxygen. The Pauling electronegativities are

χ(Cl)=3.0,  χ(Br)=2.8,  χ(I)=2.5.\chi(\mathrm{Cl}) = 3.0,\; \chi(\mathrm{Br}) = 2.8,\; \chi(\mathrm{I}) = 2.5.

Thus the stability arising only from the oxidation state follows

I>Br>Cl.\mathrm{I} > \mathrm{Br} > \mathrm{Cl}.

Now we must consider the second factor, X-O bond strength. The X-O bond is formed by the lateral overlap of the pp orbitals of X and O. A larger atomic radius leads to poorer overlap and therefore a weaker bond. The atomic radii increase down the group, so the bond strength order is

X-O bond energy:    Cl−O>Br−O>I−O.\text{X-O bond energy:}\;\; \mathrm{Cl-O} > \mathrm{Br-O} > \mathrm{I-O}.

A stronger bond clearly enhances stability; hence, by this factor alone, the order would be

Cl>Br>I.\mathrm{Cl} > \mathrm{Br} > \mathrm{I}.

To obtain the overall trend we combine both arguments. For iodine, although the I-O bond is somewhat weaker, the very large gain in stability obtained by having iodine comfortably in the +1+1 state more than compensates for the weaker bond. For bromine the I-O advantage does not exist, yet its Br-O bond is weaker than the Cl-O bond, making dibromine monoxide the least stable among the three. Hence the net order becomes

I2O  >  Cl2O  >  Br2O.\boxed{\mathrm{I}_2\mathrm{O}\; >\; \mathrm{Cl}_2\mathrm{O}\; >\; \mathrm{Br}_2\mathrm{O}}.

So iodine monoxide is the most stable, chlorine monoxide comes next, and bromine monoxide is the least stable.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Group 17: halogens and hydrogen halides. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicGroup 17: halogens and hydrogen halides
TypeMultiple choice