RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2021 · 31 AUG S1+4EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2021 Chemistry question — Group 17: halogens and hydrogen halides

The number of halogen/(s) forming halic (V) acid is _________.

SOLUTION

First, we recall that for any oxo-acid of a halogen the oxidation state of the halogen is obtained from the general expression

Oxidation state of X =(Total charge of the acid)−∑(known oxidation states of other atoms)Number of X atoms.= \frac{\text{(Total charge of the acid)}-\sum \text{(known oxidation states of other atoms)}}{\text{Number of X atoms}}.

Now, a halic (V) acid is defined as an oxo-acid of the type HXO3\mathrm{HXO_3} in which the halogen X\mathrm{X} possesses an oxidation state of +5 (Roman numeral V).+5 \, (\text{Roman numeral V}).

We examine each halogen one by one to check whether it can exhibit the +5+5 oxidation state and hence form HXO3.\mathrm{HXO_3}.

1. Fluorine (F\mathrm{F}):

Fluorine is the most electronegative element and never exhibits a positive oxidation state. Thus it cannot attain +5+5 oxidation state. Therefore no compound of the form HFO3\mathrm{HFO_3} exists.

2. Chlorine (Cl\mathrm{Cl}):

Using the formula for oxidation state in HClO3\mathrm{HClO_3} we have

x+3(−2)+1(+1)=0,x + 3(-2) + 1(+1) = 0,

which simplifies step by step as

x−6+1=0,x - 6 + 1 = 0,

x−5=0,x - 5 = 0,

x=+5.x = +5.

Since chlorine attains +5,+5, HClO3\mathrm{HClO_3} is a genuine halic (V) acid.

3. Bromine (Br\mathrm{Br}):

For HBrO3\mathrm{HBrO_3} the same calculation gives

x+3(−2)+1(+1)=0,x + 3(-2) + 1(+1) = 0,

x−6+1=0,x - 6 + 1 = 0,

x−5=0,x - 5 = 0,

x=+5.x = +5.

Hence bromine forms HBrO3,\mathrm{HBrO_3}, another halic (V) acid.

4. Iodine (I\mathrm{I}):

For HIO3\mathrm{HIO_3} we again obtain

x+3(−2)+1(+1)=0,x + 3(-2) + 1(+1) = 0,

x−6+1=0,x - 6 + 1 = 0,

x−5=0,x - 5 = 0,

x=+5.x = +5.

Thus iodine also forms a stable halic (V) acid HIO3.\mathrm{HIO_3}.

Summarising our findings, the halogens that can form halic (V) acids are Cl,Br,\mathrm{Cl}, \mathrm{Br}, and I.\mathrm{I}. Fluorine is excluded. Therefore the count of such halogens is

3.3.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Group 17: halogens and hydrogen halides. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicGroup 17: halogens and hydrogen halides
TypeNumerical answer