RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2023 · 24 JAN S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2023 Chemistry question — Group 15: trends and hydrides

Which of the Phosphorus oxoacid can create silver mirror from AgNO3_3 solution?

SOLUTION

We need to identify which phosphorus oxoacid can reduce AgNO3AgNO_3 to metallic silver (creating a silver mirror, i.e., giving a positive Tollen's test). A phosphorus oxoacid can act as a strong reducing agent if it contains a direct P−HP-H bond because the hydrogen bonded directly to phosphorus can be released, providing electrons for the reduction process. Oxoacids with P−HP-H bonds are strong enough reducing agents to reduce Ag+Ag^+ ions to metallic silver. Metaphosphoric acid HPO3nHPO_{3n} (polymetaphosphoric acid) has the structure where all hydrogen atoms are bonded to oxygen as O−HO-H groups and no direct P−HP-H bond; therefore it cannot reduce Ag+Ag^+ to silver.

Pyrophosphorous acid H4P2O5H_4P_2O_5, the pyro-form of phosphorous acid H3PO3H_3PO_3, retains the direct P−HP-H bonds present in phosphorous acid. Since phosphorous acid is diprotic with one hydrogen bonded to phosphorus, the condensation of two H3PO3H_3PO_3 molecules (losing water) produces H4P2O5H_4P_2O_5 with the same P−HP-H bonds, and these bonds give it the reducing power to reduce Ag+Ag^+ ions to metallic silver:

Ag+(aq)+e−→Ag(s)Ag^+(aq) + e^- \rightarrow Ag(s)

Thus H4P2O5H_4P_2O_5 can create a silver mirror from AgNO3AgNO_3 solution. Hypophosphoric acid H4P2O6H_4P_2O_6 contains a direct P−PP-P bond and hydrogen atoms only bonded to oxygen as O−HO-H groups, so it lacks a P−HP-H bond and cannot reduce Ag+Ag^+. Pyrophosphoric acid H4P2O7H_4P_2O_7 (the pyro-form of phosphoric acid H3PO4H_3PO_4) also has no P−HP-H bonds since all hydrogens are in O−HO-H groups, and therefore it cannot act as a reducing agent. Only H4P2O5H_4P_2O_5 (pyrophosphorous acid) contains P−HP-H bonds, giving it the necessary reducing power to reduce Ag+Ag^+ to metallic silver and produce a silver mirror. The correct answer is Option 2: H4P2O5H_4P_2O_5.

Tagged Group 15: trends and hydrides. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicGroup 15: trends and hydrides
TypeMultiple choice