RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2009TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2009 Chemistry question — Group 18: noble gases and xenon compounds

Which one of the following reactions of Xenon compounds is not feasible?

SOLUTION

First, recall the stable oxidation states and the usual inter-conversions of xenon compounds.

• In XeF2,XeF4,XeF_2, XeF_4, and XeF6XeF_6 the oxidation state of xenon is +2,+4+2,+4 and +6+6 respectively.
• In XeO3XeO_3 xenon is also in the +6+6 state, but the Xe-O bond is much stronger and far less labile than the Xe-F bond because oxygen is doubly bonded to xenon through pπ−dπp\pi-d\pi back bonding.
• Replacing -O- by -F- therefore needs a very strong fluorinating agent such as F2F_2, ClF3ClF_3 or BrF5BrF_5; anhydrous HFHF is far too weak.

Now analyse each option.

Option A
XeO3+6HF→XeF6+3H2OXeO_3 + 6HF \rightarrow XeF_6 + 3H_2O
Both xenon compounds are in the same oxidation state +6+6, so the reaction, if it occurred, would merely exchange O ligands for F ligands. HF is only a weak fluorinating agent (it is in fact routinely produced as a by-product when XeFn are hydrolysed). It cannot break the strong Xe-O bonds present in XeO3XeO_3, hence this conversion is not feasible under ordinary conditions.

Option B
3XeF4+6H2O→2Xe+XeO3+12HF+1.5O23XeF_4 + 6H_2O \rightarrow 2Xe + XeO_3 + 12HF + 1.5O_2
Hydrolysis of XeF4XeF_4 is well documented. Fluoride ions are protonated to give HFHF, xenon is partly reduced to the elemental state and partly oxidised to XeO3XeO_3, and dioxygen is released. Therefore this reaction is feasible.

Option C
2XeF2+2H2O→2Xe+4HF+O22XeF_2 + 2H_2O \rightarrow 2Xe + 4HF + O_2
XeF2XeF_2 undergoes auto-redox (disproportionation) in water exactly as written, giving back xenon gas, HFHF and O2O_2. The reaction is experimentally observed, so it is feasible.

Option D
XeF6+RbF→Rb[XeF7]XeF_6 + RbF \rightarrow Rb[XeF_7]
Addition of a fluoride ion to XeF6XeF_6 produces the heptafluoroxenate(VI) anion [XeF7]−[XeF_7]^-. Alkali-metal salts such as Cs[XeF7]Cs[XeF_7] and Rb[XeF7]Rb[XeF_7] are isolable solids; hence this reaction is also feasible.

Only Option A involves replacing strong Xe-O bonds by Xe-F bonds using weak HF, which is not possible. All the other reactions are standard hydrolysis or fluoride-addition processes that do occur.

Therefore the reaction that is not feasible is:

Option A which is: XeO3+6HF→XeF6+3H2OXeO_3 + 6HF \to XeF_6 + 3H_2O

Tagged Group 18: noble gases and xenon compounds. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicGroup 18: noble gases and xenon compounds
TypeMultiple choice