RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2005TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2005 Chemistry question — Group 17: halogens and hydrogen halides

The correct order of the thermal stability of hydrogen halides (H-X) is

SOLUTION

Thermal stability of a hydrogen halide H ⁣− ⁣X\mathrm{H\!-\!X} depends on the ease with which the H ⁣− ⁣X\mathrm{H\!-\!X} bond breaks on heating. A stronger bond (higher bond dissociation enthalpy) resists thermal decomposition better, giving greater stability.

For the halogens F,  Cl,  Br,  I\mathrm{F,\;Cl,\;Br,\;I} the factors that control H ⁣− ⁣X\mathrm{H\!-\!X} bond strength are:

(i) Bond length — increases down the group because the halogen atom gets larger.
(ii) Overlap efficiency — decreases down the group; poorer overlap makes the bond weaker.
(iii) Ionic character — though H ⁣− ⁣F\mathrm{H\!-\!F} is highly polar, the bond is short and very strong. Going down the group, polarity drops only slightly but length increases markedly, so bond energy falls.

Experimentally the bond dissociation enthalpies (in kJ mol−1\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}) are approximately
D0(H ⁣− ⁣F)≈565;  D0(H ⁣− ⁣Cl)≈431;  D0(H ⁣− ⁣Br)≈366;  D0(H ⁣− ⁣I)≈299D_{0}(\mathrm{H\!-\!F}) \approx 565;\; D_{0}(\mathrm{H\!-\!Cl}) \approx 431;\; D_{0}(\mathrm{H\!-\!Br}) \approx 366;\; D_{0}(\mathrm{H\!-\!I}) \approx 299

Because the bond energy decreases steadily from HF\mathrm{HF} to HI\mathrm{HI}, resistance to thermal decomposition follows the same order:

HF>HCl>HBr>HI\mathrm{HF} \gt \mathrm{HCl} \gt \mathrm{HBr} \gt \mathrm{HI}

Hence the correct order of thermal stability is

Option B which is: HF > HCl > HBr > HI

Tagged Group 17: halogens and hydrogen halides. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicGroup 17: halogens and hydrogen halides
TypeMultiple choice