RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 10 JAN S2+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Chemistry question — Group 17: halogens and hydrogen halides

Among the following reactions of hydrogen with halogens, the one that requires a catalyst is:

SOLUTION

We recall the general order of chemical reactivity of the halogens toward molecular hydrogen. Experimental data and bond-dissociation energies tell us that the ease with which the reactions

H2+X2⟶2HXH_2 + X_2 \longrightarrow 2HX

proceed in the gas phase decreases in the sequence

F2  >  Cl2  >  Br2  >  I2.F_2 \; > \; Cl_2 \; > \; Br_2 \; > \; I_2.

This trend can be justified by comparing the bond strengths of the covalent bonds X ⁣− ⁣XX\!-\!X and H ⁣− ⁣XH\!-\!X along the group. The lighter halogens form weaker X ⁣− ⁣XX\!-\!X bonds but stronger H ⁣− ⁣XH\!-\!X bonds, making the overall enthalpy change more negative (that is, more exothermic) and the activation energy lower. As we go down the group, the X ⁣− ⁣XX\!-\!X bond becomes stronger relative to the H ⁣− ⁣XH\!-\!X bond that is to be formed, so the reaction becomes less spontaneous and increasingly sluggish.

Let us examine each option in the light of this trend.

(i) For H2+F2H_2 + F_2 we have a violent, practically instantaneous reaction even in the dark at low temperatures because the driving force is very large. Therefore no catalyst is required.

(ii) For H2+Cl2H_2 + Cl_2 the reaction is also fast, although it usually needs initiation by light (photochemical initiation) rather than a chemical catalyst. Again, no catalyst is necessary; mere exposure to light is enough.

(iii) For H2+Br2H_2 + Br_2 the reaction rate drops significantly. Ordinarily, gentle heating or strong light is supplied to accelerate the process, but a separate chemical species acting as a catalyst is still not indispensable.

(iv) For H2+I2H_2 + I_2 the reaction is the slowest of all because the enthalpy change is almost thermoneutral and the activation energy is high. To obtain an appreciable rate at moderate temperature one introduces a catalyst such as finely divided platinum, palladium or moist red phosphorus. The catalyst provides an alternate pathway of lower activation energy by adsorbing both H2H_2 and I2I_2 on its surface, dissociating them into atoms, and allowing them to recombine as HIHI. Without this catalytic assistance the direct homogeneous reaction is practically negligible under ordinary laboratory conditions.

Consequently, among the four reactions listed, only

H2+I2⟶2HIH_2 + I_2 \longrightarrow 2HI

unequivocally requires a catalyst to proceed at a reasonable rate. The others may need light or heat but not a chemical catalyst.

Hence, the correct answer is Option 2.

Tagged Group 17: halogens and hydrogen halides. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicGroup 17: halogens and hydrogen halides
TypeMultiple choice