RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 10 APR S2+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Chemistry question — Group 15: trends and hydrides

The number of pentagons in C60_{60} and trigons (triangles) in white phosphorus, are;

SOLUTION

We begin with the fullerene molecule C60\mathrm{C}_{60}, commonly called buckminsterfullerene. Its carbon atoms occupy the vertices of a polyhedron that is topologically identical to a soccer ball, i.e. a truncated icosahedron. In such a solid we observe that two types of regular polygons are present: pentagons and hexagons. Let us let PP denote the number of pentagons, HH denote the number of hexagons, FF denote the total number of faces, EE the total number of edges and VV the total number of vertices.

First, the truncated icosahedron has V=60V = 60 because there are sixty carbon atoms. Every carbon atom is bonded to three others, so every vertex is of degree 33. Because each edge is shared by exactly two vertices, we have the relation

2E=3V.2E = 3V.

Substituting V=60V = 60 gives

2E=3×60=180,2E = 3 \times 60 = 180,

so

E=1802=90.E = \frac{180}{2} = 90.

Next we write Euler’s polyhedral formula, which states

V−E+F=2.V - E + F = 2.

Placing the known values V=60V = 60 and E=90E = 90, we have

60−90+F=2,60 - 90 + F = 2,

so

F=2+90−60=32.F = 2 + 90 - 60 = 32.

Thus the truncated icosahedron has 3232 faces in total. These faces consist only of pentagons and hexagons, so

F=P+H.F = P + H.

Therefore

P+H=32.−(1)P + H = 32. \quad-(\text{1})

Now we examine the edge count in terms of faces. A pentagon possesses 55 edges and a hexagon possesses 66 edges. Because each edge belongs to exactly two faces, the following relation also holds:

5P+6H=2E.5P + 6H = 2E.

We already calculated E=90E = 90, hence

5P+6H=2×90=180.−(2)5P + 6H = 2 \times 90 = 180. \quad-(\text{2})

We now have two simultaneous linear equations, (1) and (2), in the unknowns PP and HH:

P+H=32,5P+6H=180.\begin{aligned} P + H &= 32, \\ 5P + 6H &= 180. \end{aligned}

To solve them, we first express HH from the first equation:

H=32−P.H = 32 - P.

Substituting this into the second equation gives

5P+6(32−P)=180.5P + 6(32 - P) = 180.

Simplifying, we obtain

5P+192−6P=180,5P + 192 - 6P = 180,

which reduces to

(5P−6P)+192=180,(5P - 6P) + 192 = 180,

so

−P+192=180.-P + 192 = 180.

Therefore

−P=180−192=−12,-P = 180 - 192 = -12,

and hence

P=12.P = 12.

Substituting P=12P = 12 back into H=32−PH = 32 - P gives

H=32−12=20.H = 32 - 12 = 20.

Thus the fullerene C60\mathrm{C}_{60} contains 1212 pentagonal faces.

Now we turn our attention to white phosphorus, whose molecular formula is P4\mathrm{P}_{4}. In white phosphorus, four phosphorus atoms occupy the corners of a regular tetrahedron. A tetrahedron is defined as the polyhedron possessing four triangular faces, six edges and four vertices. Therefore, the number of triangular faces, which the question calls trigons, equals the total count of faces of a tetrahedron, namely

number of triangles=4.\text{number of triangles} = 4.

So, for white phosphorus P4\mathrm{P}_{4}, there are exactly four triangular faces.

Combining the two parts, we have

Pentagons in C60=12,Triangles in white phosphorus=4.\begin{aligned} \text{Pentagons in } \mathrm{C}_{60} &= 12,\\ \text{Triangles in white phosphorus} &= 4. \end{aligned}

Examining the options, we see that these values correspond to Option D, which lists “12 and 4”.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Group 15: trends and hydrides. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicGroup 15: trends and hydrides
TypeMultiple choice